NOV 3, 2026 ≈72 MIN AI-GENERATED

11/3/26 City Council Meeting

Council tightens homeless camping ordinance

Listen to this meeting
1 hr 12 min · the full official recording, playable right here
Watch the full meeting →
TL;DR

The council's main decision was a second round of changes to Chico's ordinance on camping on public property: after a motion to delay the vote until the city's broader homelessness plan is finished failed 3-4, the council passed an amended version of the ordinance 5-2, adding provisions that cleared areas must stay clear and that a camper's required 48-hour warning and shelter assessment need only be given once. The consent agenda — routine items bundled into a single vote — passed 7-0, with two members registering no votes on the related ordinance restricting camping in parks. The Finance Committee reported that the city's unfunded pension liability sits at about $167 million, down from the prior year but still a concern. Public comment ranged from a proposed low-cost shelter model to unrelated complaints about local media and public health. The council also voted to direct staff to bring back a redrafted shopping cart ordinance.

What happened, item by item

ITEM 1.5 Not in the recording
Proclamation: Homeless Youth Awareness Month

The council was scheduled to proclaim November as Homeless Youth Awareness Month, presented by representatives of the Butte County Office of Education. The recording does not capture this portion of the meeting clearly enough to report further detail.

Consent agenda (items 2.1–2.8)

The consent agenda bundles routine items into a single vote. This batch included final adoption of an ordinance updating park rules, a related ordinance restricting camping in parks, a year-end budget adjustment, a budget change to fund new Police Department staffing and $15,500 in redaction software for public records requests, two utility easement purchases tied to the North Esplanade reconstruction project, final maps for two housing subdivisions (Autumn Leaf Estates Phase 2 and a Habitat for Humanity project on Wisconsin Street), and approval of prior meeting minutes. One speaker addressed the consent agenda, urging the council to consider a "tiny home" shelter model as a lower-cost alternative to repeated encampment sweeps, saying "let's save some money and clean up our parks and downtowns, too," and arguing such programs cost roughly $4,000 per resident per year compared to an estimated $80,000 per year for someone who remains unsheltered. The consent agenda passed 7-0, with Councilmembers Goldstein and Hawley recorded as no votes on item 2.2, the camping-in-parks ordinance.

ITEM 5.1
Ordinance regulating camping on public property

This item returned for further changes to an ordinance governing homeless camping on city property, part of an ongoing revision process shaped by the Warren Settlement Agreement — a legal settlement that requires the city to give notice and a shelter assessment before clearing an encampment. At the prior meeting the council had already changed how many days someone may sleep overnight in a recreational vehicle, moving it from the original seven days to three and then, as a compromise, to five; it had also extended the city's notice requirement from 24 to 48 hours.

Before voting on the ordinance itself, the council considered a motion to table the item until the city's five-year Unhoused Strategic Plan — then gathering public input and headed to the council on November 17 — could provide more data to guide any changes. That motion failed 3-4.

The council then voted on the ordinance as amended from the dais by Councilmember O'Brien, who said the version in front of the council had "a significant omission." His amendment added two things: that once an area such as a playground, bike path, or creek is cleared of camping, it must stay clear, and that once a person receives the 48-hour warning and a shelter assessment, the city does not have to repeat that same warning to the same person every time. Supporters argued this closes a loophole in which someone could move a short distance away, restart the 48-hour clock, and create a repeating cycle the city has dealt with for years; Chico Police Department leadership confirmed the department already has a dispatch system that can flag whether a person has previously received a warning, making a one-time notice workable without extra burden on officers.

Opponents raised several concerns. One member argued that lowering the recreational-vehicle camping allowance to five days instead of the original seven was a last-minute, arbitrary change made at the prior meeting, when every public speaker and several council members had argued against shortening it. Others said the new "stays clear" language left basic questions unanswered, such as how close a camper could move before being considered back in a cleared area, and suggested the city instead adopt a model ordinance circulated by the governor's office, which defines a 200-foot buffer around a cleared site and specific "exigent circumstances" for sensitive areas like waterways. Several members also said amending the ordinance clause-by-clause from the dais, while the city was simultaneously developing its broader Unhoused Strategic Plan, risked locking in details without enough data or community input, and preferred to handle any changes as part of that larger plan.

Two residents spoke on the item. One, Lynn Oberholzer, thanked the council for its handling of encampments near her neighborhood, saying "that side of Chico is so much better than it used to be after the alternative site was cleaned up," and added, "I understand very well what the Warren Settlement Agreement was. I've read it," pushing back on criticism that the council hadn't done enough. The second speaker argued the city's broader approach prioritizes enforcement over housing, saying "housing is the issue, homelessness is the outcome," and cited city data showing Chico has met only a small fraction of its state low-income housing targets over the past two decades while exceeding its higher-income targets.

The motion to table failed 3-4 (yes: Goldstein, Hawley, Winslow; no: O'Brien, van Overbeek, Bennett, Reynolds). The amended ordinance then passed 5-2 (yes: O'Brien, van Overbeek, Winslow, Bennett, Reynolds; no: Goldstein, Hawley). Because the ordinance was amended from the floor, staff said it will need to come back for at least one more reading before taking effect.

ITEM 5.2
Finance Committee report

The Finance Committee chair presented an update on CalPERS, the state pension system, reporting the city's combined unfunded pension liability is about $167 million, funded at 71% — an improvement from roughly $180 million a year earlier, driven by stronger investment returns. The city's required annual payment toward that shortfall is about $17.5 million for the coming fiscal year, projected to rise to about $18.5 million the year after. No council vote was required; the committee also plans to review the city's insurance and risk-management strategy, its cash investment policy, and to start receiving quarterly budget-versus-actual updates.

ITEM 6.1
City Manager's report

City Manager Gillian Haen gave a verbal update: a public town hall on the draft Unhoused Strategic Plan was scheduled for the following evening, with the plan itself headed to the council on November 17; she described attending a national city managers' conference, a Fire Academy live burn exercise, Cal Water's 100th anniversary event, and the Treat Street Halloween event with the police chief and fire marshal. She also announced that Community Development Director Brendan Vieg is departing and that the city has engaged a search firm, Bob Marine Associates, to begin recruiting a replacement. No vote was taken.

ITEM 6.2
Councilmember requests

A councilmember asked staff to redraft the city's shopping cart ordinance so that responsibility for retrieving stray carts falls more clearly on retailers, arguing that someone in possession of an abandoned cart is effectively holding stolen property. The request to put this on a future agenda passed 7-0.

SAID ON THE DAIS

“That side of Chico is so much better than it used to be after the alternative site was cleaned up.”

— LYNN OBERHOLZER, RESIDENT

Votes & roll calls

ITEM 2 CONSENT AGENDA
✓ PASSED 7–0
✓ Goldstein ✓ Hawley ✓ O'Brien ✓ van Overbeek ✓ Winslow ✓ Bennett ✓ Reynolds

Votes on individual items

  • Goldstein and Hawley voted no on item 2.2. 2.2 · ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CHICO AMENDING TITLE 12R OF THE CITY OF CHICO MUNICIPAL CODE TO REGULATE CERTAIN ACTS OF CAMPING IN PARKS

The consent agenda is approved as one motion, so the roll call above is the vote on the whole bundle, recorded as the clerk called it. Before that vote, these members said they were voting differently on the items listed.

ITEM 5.1 ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CHICO AMENDING TITLE 9, OF THE CITY OF CHICO MUNICIPAL CODE TO REGULATE CERTAIN ACTS OF CAMPING ON PUBLIC PROPERTY

After the substitute motion to table failed 3-4, the council returned to Councilmember O'Brien's original motion seconded by Councilmember van Overbeek.

Main motion ✓ PASSED 5–2
✗ Goldstein ✗ Hawley ✓ O'Brien ✓ van Overbeek ✓ Winslow ✓ Bennett ✓ Reynolds
How they got there (1)

↳ Substitute motion to table the item; after it failed 3-4 the council fell back to the original motion by Councilmember O'Brien.

Substitute ✗ FAILED 3–4
✓ Goldstein ✓ Hawley ✗ O'Brien ✗ van Overbeek ✓ Winslow ✗ Bennett ✗ Reynolds
ITEM 6.2 COUNCILMEMBER REQUESTS
✓ PASSED 7–0
✓ Goldstein ✓ Hawley ✓ O'Brien ✓ van Overbeek ✓ Winslow ✓ Bennett ✓ Reynolds

Notable moments

  • The meeting opened with an audio problem — strings of "test" and silent "you" cues in the recording — before staff confirmed the stream was fixed on all platforms and thanked a remote service provider for troubleshooting it.
  • In her report, the city manager noted she was the first Chico city manager to suit up and go through a live fire exercise with Fire Academy recruits, and that the city held its first-ever candidate orientation session for people running for local office.
  • Explaining his vote in favor of the amended camping ordinance, one member said he feared that without the changes, the city would otherwise face "a repetitious procedure" similar to what it has experienced over the past five years under the settlement.

Public comment

Two people spoke during the general public comment period, and both raised subjects unrelated to items on the agenda.

  • One speaker, Bo Powell, criticized Action News Now's management for not returning his calls and alleged a cover-up related to agricultural pesticide spraying (naming methyl bromide), along with claims about a past overpayment from Butte County to the city and allegations involving police and fire department raises; these claims were not substantiated by other sources in the meeting.
  • A second speaker, Kevin Walters, raised concerns about COVID-19 vaccines, calling for them to be stopped, and also referenced unrelated topics including chemtrails and abortion.
Coming up
  • A public town hall on the draft Unhoused Strategic Plan is scheduled for the evening after this meeting (6–8 p.m., Council Chamber).
  • The Unhoused Strategic Plan itself is scheduled for council consideration on November 17.
  • The camping-on-public-property ordinance (item 5.1) will return for at least one more reading to formalize the amendments adopted at this meeting.
  • A redraft of the shopping cart ordinance will come back to the council for discussion at a future meeting.
  • The next council meeting is November 17, with the regular meeting at 6:00 p.m. (closed session beforehand, starting at 5:00 or 5:30 p.m.)