11/17/26 City Council Meeting
Chico adopts new homelessness plan
The Chico City Council unanimously adopted a new two-year Unhoused Strategic Plan to guide the city's response to homelessness once the Warren settlement expires on January 14, 2027, and approved $300,000 in opioid settlement funding to help implement it. The council also confirmed a new fire deputy chief, approved a raise and new contract term for the City Clerk, and gave final approval to an updated anti-camping ordinance as part of the routine consent agenda. In a closer vote, the council directed staff to restart the sewer rate public-hearing process using a revised billing methodology and a cash-funded (rather than debt-financed) approach, passing 6-1 with Mayor Kasey Reynolds dissenting. Public comment ranged from neighborhood traffic complaints to pesticide-spraying concerns to support for downtown shopping events.
What happened, item by item
The bundled consent agenda — including final adoption of an updated ordinance regulating camping on public property, a traffic regulation update lowering posted speed limits on Bruce Road, and authorization for the city to assign a loan and grant agreement tied to the Longfellow Apartments low-income housing project — passed 7-0. Item 2.3, a budget modification to pay for survey work to clean up property boundaries near the Manzanita and Eaton Road roundabout, was pulled from the consent bundle for separate consideration; the recording doesn't show it being taken up again afterward.
The council confirmed Philip Stelle as the city's new Deputy Fire Chief, with an annual salary of $185,000, as required under the City Charter. The vote passed 7-0.
The council approved a second amendment to City Clerk Deborah Presson's employment agreement, providing a 5% salary increase retroactive to July 12, 2026, and a further 5.5% increase effective January 10, 2027, along with a new three-year contract term running through June 30, 2029. The vote passed 7-0.
The council considered a draft Unhoused Strategic Plan setting six goals and originally 18 (later 19) priority actions to guide the city's homelessness response for 2027-2029, following the January 14, 2027 expiration of the Warren v. City of Chico settlement. City Manager Gillian Haen described it as "a guidance document," not "a regulatory document," built from feedback gathered at a service-provider meeting, a community town hall, a session with people who have experienced homelessness, and dozens of emails and one-on-one conversations. Based on that feedback, staff shortened the plan's timeline from five years to two, raised the goal for reducing unsheltered homelessness from a 25% to a 50% cut within two years, and added a strategy to support nonprofit partners interested in options like managed campgrounds or tiny homes. Before voting, the council added two amendments: expanding a mapping action item to track waterways and bike paths in addition to wildfire-risk areas, and requiring staff to report back to council every six months rather than just once. The plan was adopted 7-0, and a related $300,000 supplemental appropriation of opioid settlement funds — $200,000 for Public Works cleanup and harm-reduction efforts and $100,000 for police overtime tied to opioid outreach — also passed 7-0.
The council considered a continued Proposition 218 hearing — a legally required public process for raising certain utility fees — on sewer rates. Staff proposed a revised rate methodology that replaces the current mix of fixed and volume-based charges for commercial customers with a simpler fixed charge plus a volumetric rate weighted by waste "strength," which shifts some cost burden from commercial customers (like restaurants) to the larger residential customer base. The underlying $106 million capital improvement plan and revenue needs were unchanged; what the council had to decide was how to pay for the increase — fully through rates paid in cash, or by taking out up to $40-60 million in debt to spread out the impact.
The case for the cash-funded option, which several members and staff favored, was that debt financing would ultimately cost ratepayers more: a $40 million loan was projected to cost roughly $60 million over its life, for a savings of only about $12 a month on an average residential bill in the near term. Supporters argued that committing to 20 years of debt for a relatively small short-term benefit wasn't worth it, and that the city could always pursue debt financing later if circumstances changed.
The case against — reflected in Mayor Reynolds's dissenting vote — was that the methodology and amount still weren't clearly right. The mayor noted that a previous council had been assured a past rate increase would be sufficient, and it wasn't, and questioned how long businesses would have to struggle with higher bills before rates might ever be revisited downward. Business groups, including the Chico Chamber of Commerce and Chico Builders Association, also raised concerns during public comment that the timeline for independent review was too short and that the revised methodology still shifted costs onto residential ratepayers without fully proving no cheaper option existed. One resident on a fixed income told the council that the proposed roughly 35% increase in his bill was unrealistic to absorb, saying, "I don't have an extra $17 a month to grab out of thin air. I don't know where you folks think I'm supposed to get it from. I got to tighten the belt, so why can't you?"
Staff noted a legal and financial backdrop to the debate: about half of the needed $106 million is tied to a state regulatory mandate, and if the city doesn't raise rates enough to fund required infrastructure, the state could step in and take over management of the sewer system and raise rates itself.
The council voted 6-1, with Mayor Reynolds opposed, to direct staff to initiate a new Prop 218 notice based on the revised billing methodology and a cash-funded financing approach. A new public hearing and final rate adoption is expected in February 2027, with the first rate increase to take effect in April 2027 if approved.
Votes & roll calls
Present: Goldstein, Hawley, O'Brien, van Overbeek, Winslow, Bennett, Reynolds
Notable moments
- The recording's live stream was down for about the first two minutes of the meeting, so the audio begins partway through, as the council was wrapping up closed session.
- Several public speakers exceeded their allotted time and were warned by the mayor and city clerk to stop interrupting the meeting; one speaker was asked to move signage to the back of the room.
- After a Butte County supervisor raised concerns that the city's plan might duplicate or overstep the county-run Continuum of Care system, Councilmember Hawley asked staff to clarify the city's intentions, and City Manager Haen responded that the city is not seeking to take over any of the Continuum of Care's role, only to strengthen the partnership.
- A commenter's video call connection on Zoom initially failed during the sewer rate hearing, and after some technical back-and-forth the speaker was successfully reconnected to deliver his comment.
Public comment
About eight residents spoke during the general public comment period, with topics ranging widely rather than clustering on one issue.
- Two speakers raised traffic safety concerns in the same neighborhood, with one asking the city to "encourage several speed bumps and white stripes on Sheridan Avenue between Palmetto and First Avenue to get drivers to slow down" and to consider red light cameras at Palmetto and Sheridan.
- A longtime resident announced she has formed a new group, the Valenbrosia Avenue Coalition, to represent roughly 110 single-family homes and 94 condos along that street on issues including park camping rules and an upcoming 2028 road project.
- One speaker raised concerns about agricultural pesticide spraying setbacks near Butte County orchards, arguing local rules allow spraying closer to schools than state law permits.
- A few speakers raised broader, less verifiable claims about chemical contamination and public health that the transcript doesn't support fact-checking.
- A speaker criticized the city's new anti-camping ordinance as a human-rights violation, saying "we need to have accountability, have these people held accountable and come together to build the town we want."
- A downtown event organizer thanked the council for its continued support of free parking Fridays, which resume downtown on November 27, 2026, and announced the second annual "Pink Friday" shopping event on November 20, 2026, saying "I'm so happy to see hope is returning."
- The council adjourns to its next meeting on December 1, 2026, with closed session at 5:00 or 5:30 p.m. followed by the regular meeting at 6:00 p.m.
- The Unhoused Strategic Plan and its new enforcement rules take effect January 15, 2027, the day after the Warren settlement expires; staff will report back to the council on implementation every six months.
- The city's winter cold-weather shelters open December 1, 2026.
- A new Proposition 218 notice on sewer rates will go out to customers, with a follow-up public hearing and rate adoption expected in February 2027 and the first new rate taking effect in April 2027.
Every item as published on the official agenda. Timestamps play the moment that item came up. The recap tab covers what actually happened.
- 1. CALL TO ORDER - November 17, 2026, City Council Meeting
- 1.1. ROLL CALL
- 1.1. Invocation - Chaplain Bud Chauvin
- 1.2. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag
- 1.3. Roll Call
- 1.4. November 17, 2026, Closed Session Announcements - City Attorney Ryan R. Jones
- 2. CONSENT AGENDA - All matters listed under the Consent Agenda are to be considered routine in nature.
- 2.1. ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CHICO AMENDING TITLE 9, OF THE CITY OF CHICO MUNICIPAL CODE TO REGULATE CERTAIN ACTS OF CAMPING ON PUBLIC PROPERTY - final reading and adoption by reading of title only Adopt - an ordinance amending Title 9.20 of the Chico Municipal Code regulating camping on public property. At its meeting of 10/20/26, the Council requested several amendments to the original ordinance that was introduced. At its meeting of 11/3/26, additional amendments were requested. Both the red line and final versions of the ordinance are being provided for transparency and clarification of the changes. staff report ↗
- 2.2. TRA 880 E&TS ADOPTION - BRUCE ROAD Adopt - Traffic Regulation Amendment (TRA 880), updating posted speed limits as shown in Exhibit 19a. California Vehicle Code Sections 40802 and 40803 sets the frequency and criteria for conducting speed surveys. To ensure that enforcement by radar on certain streets remains valid in a court of law, the City must conduct radar speed surveys every seven years. (Brendan Ottoboni, Director of Public Works - Engineering) staff report ↗
- 2.4. AUTHORIZATION FOR THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN ASSIGNMENT AND ASSUMPTION OF A LOAN AND GRANT AGREEMENT AND REGULATORY AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF CHICO AND LONGFELLOW, LLC, FOR THE LOW-INCOME HOUSING PROJECT LOCATED AT 2100 MARIPOSA, APN 048-263-032 - LONGFELLOW APARTMENTS Approve - minute order authorizing City Manager to execute an Assignment and Assumption Agreement and any other documents necessary to facilitate the transfer of ownership of Longfellow Apartments, subject to approval as to form by the City Attorney. (MaryJo Alonzo, Housing Program Manager) staff report ↗
- 2.5. ITEMS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA
- 2.3. SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION/BUDGET MODIFICATION NO. 2027-PWE-002 Approve - a Supplemental Appropriation/Budget Modification to the FY 2026-27 Budget to allocate funding to support professional surveying and mapping services necessary to complete right-of-way and property boundary line clean up in the vicinity of the Manzanita and Eaton Road Roundabout. (Brendan Ottoboni, Director of Public Works - Engineering) staff report ↗
- 3. PUBLIC COMMENTS - Members of the public may address the Council at this time on any matter not already listed on the agenda and within the jurisdiction’s authority. Comments will be limited to three minutes or as determined by the Mayor based on the number of speakers. The Council cannot take any action at this meeting on requests made under this section of the agenda.
- 4. REGULAR AGENDA
- 4.1. CONFIRMATION OF DEPUTY CHIEF - FIRE Section 605 of the City Charter states that the appointment of department heads is subject to confirmation by the City Council. In order to meet this requirement, City Council is being presented with the employment agreement for the Deputy Chief - Fire. (Report - Gillian Haen, City Manager) Recommendation : In compliance with Government Code Section 54953(c)(3), the City Manager shall first orally report a summary of the recommendation for final action related to the Deputy Chief - Fire's employment agreement as follows: "The City Manager is proposing to enter into an employment agreement with Philip Stelle as the Deputy Chief - Fire and the City Manager is proposing to appoint Philip Stelle with an annual salary of $185,000.00." The City Manager recommends Council Confirmation of the appointment of Philip Stelle as the Deputy Chief - Fire. staff report ↗ staff report ↗
- 4.2. SECOND AMENDMENT TO AMENDED CITY CLERK EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT The Second Amendment to the Amended Employment Agreement by and between Deborah R. Presson ("City Clerk") and the City of Chico ("City Clerk Employment Agreement") proposes to amend Section 2.a of the City Clerk Employment Agreement to provide for a five percent (5%) general salary increase retroactive from July 12, 2026, and a five and a half percent (5.5%) general salary increase commencing January 10, 2027, to the City Clerk’s base salary. The proposed Second Amendment also amends Section 4 (Term; Termination) to establish a three-year term commencing July 1,2026, and continuing through June 30, 2029, unless earlier terminated in accordance with the Agreement. Except as expressly amended, all remaining terms and conditions remain unchanged. (Report - Ryan Jones, City Attorney) Recommendation : In compliance with Government Code Section 54953(d)(3)(A), the City Attorney shall first orally report a summary of the recommendation for final action related to the Second Amendment to the City Clerk Employment Agreement as follows: In accordance with the Brown Act, this is to announce that the City Council is considering the Second Amendment to the City Clerk Employment Agreement authorizing a five percent (5%) base salary increase from $208,549.69 per year to $218,977.17 per year, retroactive from July 12, 2026, and a five and a half percent base salary (5.5%) increase to the City Clerk's base salary, effective January 10, 2027. The proposed Second Amendment also establishes a three-year term from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2029, unless earlier terminated in accordance with the Agreement. The City Attorney recommends that the City Council consider approval of the Second Amendment to the Amended City Clerk Employment Agreement providing for the proposed salary adjustments and establishing a three-year term from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2029; and if approved, authorize the Mayor to execute the Second Amendment on behalf of the City. staff report ↗
- 4.2. SECOND AMENDMENT TO AMENDED CITY CLERK EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT The Second Amendment to the Amended Employment Agreement by and between Deborah R. Presson ("City Clerk") and the City of Chico ("City Clerk Employment Agreement") proposes to amend Section 2.a of the City Clerk Employment Agreement to provide for a five percent (5%) general salary increase retroactive from July 12, 2026, and a five and a half percent (5.5%) general salary increase commencing January 10, 2027, to the City Clerk’s base salary. The proposed Second Amendment also amends Section 4 (Term; Termination) to establish a three-year term commencing July 1,2026, and continuing through June 30, 2029, unless earlier terminated in accordance with the Agreement. Except as expressly amended, all remaining terms and conditions remain unchanged. (Report - Ryan Jones, City Attorney) Recommendation : In compliance with Government Code Section 54953(d)(3)(A), the City Attorney shall first orally report a summary of the recommendation for final action related to the Second Amendment to the City Clerk Employment Agreement as follows: In accordance with the Brown Act, this is to announce that the City Council is considering the Second Amendment to the City Clerk Employment Agreement authorizing a five percent (5%) base salary increase from $208,549.69 per year to $218,977.17 per year, retroactive from July 12, 2026, and a five and a half percent base salary (5.5%) increase to the City Clerk's base salary, effective January 10, 2027. The proposed Second Amendment also establishes a three-year term from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2029, unless earlier terminated in accordance with the Agreement. The City Attorney recommends that the City Council consider approval of the Second Amendment to the Amended City Clerk Employment Agreement providing for the proposed salary adjustments and establishing a three-year term from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2029; and if approved, authorize the Mayor to execute the Second Amendment on behalf of the City.
- 4.3. CONSIDERATION AND ADOPTION OF THE CITY OF CHICO UNHOUSED STRATEGIC PLAN The City has developed a draft Unhoused Strategic Plan to guide our response to homelessness over the next three years, 2027 through 2029. The plan establishes an overarching framework for coordinating outreach, shelter, housing pathways, public space management, regional partnerships, and measurable outcomes. It builds on the short-term post-settlement initiatives approved by Council on May 19, 2026, while identifying six goals and nineteen priority actions for the first year of implementation following the January 14, 2027 expiration of the Warren vs. City of Chico Settlement Agreement. (Report - Gillian Haen, City Manager) Recommendation : The City Manager recommends that City Council adopt the resolution and approve the Unhoused Strategic Plan for implementation, working towards the six goals, all nineteen first year action priorities, and approve use of opioid settlement funding totaling $300,000 for plan implementation in a separate resolution. RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHICO ADOPTING THE CITY OF CHICO UNHOUSED STRATEGIC PLAN staff report ↗
- 4.4. SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION 2027-ASD-003 - OPIOID SETTLEMENT FUNDS The Administrative Services Director requests consideration and approval of Supplemental Appropriation 2027-ASD-003, a $300,000 supplemental appropriation from Opioid Settlement Funds to support implementation of the City’s Unhoused Strategic Plan. The funding includes $200,000 for Public Works - Operations and Maintenance to support coordinated harm-reduction and drug-related hazardous material mitigation efforts, and $100,000 for Police overtime associated with opioid-related outreach, prevention, and intervention activities. All expenditures will be subject to applicable opioid settlement funding requirements. (Report - Barbara Martin, Administrative Services Director) Recommendation : The Administrative Services Director recommends approval of Supplemental Appropriation 2027-ASD-003 staff report ↗
- 4.5. ITEMS ADDED AFTER THE POSTING OF THE AGENDA
- 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS
- 5.1. SEWER RATE ADJUSTMENT - PUBLIC HEARING (CONTINUED FROM 09/15/26) On September 15, 2026, the City Council continued the Proposition 218 public hearing to allow staff additional time to evaluate the proposed sewer rate methodology and associated customer impacts. Since that time, staff have worked with the City’s rate consultant to refine the cost allocation and revenue recovery basis, which reduces proposed rate impacts to commercial customers while requiring only a modest increase for residential customers due to the substantially larger residential customer base. The revised allocation and revenue recovery basis maintains projected recovery of overall revenue requirements for the Sewer Enterprise while providing a defensible allocation of costs among customer classes consistent with industry accepted cost-of-service principles. The revised methodology simplifies the current EDU approach, with a flat rate and volumetric use. (Brendan Ottoboni, Director of Public Works - Engineering) Recommendation The Director of Public Works - Engineering recommends the City Council: 1. Continue the previously noticed Public Hearing, receive public comment, and close the Public Hearing, 2. Provide direction on a preferred rate schedule based on the revised allocation and revenue recovery bases and specify whether a cash-funded or $40M debt financed approach is preferred, 3. Direct staff to initiate a new Proposition 218 process, including preparation and distribution of the public hearing notice.
- 1. Continue the previously noticed Public Hearing, receive public comment, and close the Public Hearing,
- 2. Provide direction on a preferred rate schedule based on the revised allocation and revenue recovery bases and specify whether a cash-funded or $40M debt financed approach is preferred,
- 3. Direct staff to initiate a new Proposition 218 process, including preparation and distribution of the public hearing notice. staff report ↗
- 6. REPORTS AND COMMUNICATIONS - The following reports and communication items are provided for the Council’s information. No action can be taken on items under this section unless the Council agrees to include it on a subsequent agenda.
- 6.1. CITY MANAGER’S REPORT - Verbal Report, City Manager Gillian Haen
- 6.2. ANNUAL REBUDGETS OF FISCAL YEAR 2025-26 INTO FISCAL YEAR 2026-27 AND REPORT ON CONFIRMING SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATIONS AND INTERNAL BUDGET MODIFICATIONS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2025-26 - Information only staff report ↗ staff report ↗
- 6.3. COUNCILMEMBER REQUESTS - Pursuant to AP&P 10-10, Councilmembers may verbally request an item to be agendized at a future meeting. After stating what the item would be, a majority vote of Council is needed in order for staff to agendize.
- 7. ADJOURNMENT - Adjourn to December 1, 2026, Closed Session meeting at 5:00 p.m. or 5:30 p.m. followed by the Adjourned Regular meeting at 6:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, 421 Main Street, Chico.
- 1. CALL TO ORDER IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBER AT 421 MAIN STREET, CHICO, CA.
- 1.1. ROLL CALL
- 2. CLOSED SESSION AGENDA - Members of the public may address the Council at this time on any item on the Closed Session agenda, with comments being limited to three minutes or as determined by the Mayor based on the number of speakers.
- 2.1. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - EXISTING LITIGATION: Pursuant to Cal. Gov. Code Sec. 54956.9(a): Case No. 21CV03075 – Chantelle Hall v. City of Chico; Villa Rita Housing Partners, LP
- 2.2. PUBLIC EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION: Pursuant to Cal. Gov. Code Sec. 54957(b).Title: City Manager
- 2.3. PUBLIC EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION: Pursuant to Cal. Gov. Code Sec. 54957(b).Title: City Clerk
- 2.4. CLOSED SESSION ITEMS THAT AROSE AFTER THE POSTING OF THE AGENDA
- 3. ADJOURNMENT - Adjourn to the City Council Meeting on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at 6:00 p.m.
Machine transcript (local Whisper transcription), lightly cleaned — expect imperfections. Timestamps play that moment right here; the official video is one click away too.
We're just finishing closed session, we'll be out in about three minutes.
We'll be out in about three minutes. We're just finishing closed session, we'll be out in about three minutes. We're just finishing closed session, we'll be out in about three minutes. We're just finishing closed session, we'll be out in about three minutes. We're just finishing closed session, we'll be out in about three minutes. We're just finishing closed session, we'll be out in about three minutes. We're just finishing closed session, we'll be out in about three minutes. All right, we're gonna go ahead and get started. We'll call to order our November 17th meeting. Can we start with our invocation by Chaplain Bud? Thank you. Thank you Madam Mayor and Councilman, thanks for the opportunity.
Let's start with a word of prayer. Almighty God, we do come before you tonight. And Lord, I thank you for these men and women who have spent so much of their time overseeing our city. And I ask your blessing upon each one of them. And Lord, as they gather again tonight and discuss and decide the issues that pertain to our city, Lord, may you give them wisdom and understanding that they would be able to make those decisions that would lead our city in a way that we might, as citizens, live a comfortable and peaceful life. We thank you for them. We thank you Lord for our city workers, for the police department, the fire department, the men and women of the maintenance crew and all the things, the moving parts that make this city work.
We thank you for each and every person who works here. And ask your blessings to be poured out upon each and every one of them. And we appreciate them. And we thank you Lord. So we just ask for your guidance and wisdom and direction for this meeting. And we ask it all in your almighty name. Amen. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. Salute. And Pledge.
All right. Madam Clerk, can you call our roll for us? Sure. Council Member Goldstein. Present. Council Member Hawley. Here. Council Member O'Brien. Here. Council Member van Overbeek. Oh, sorry. Here. Council Member Winslow. Here. Vice Mayor Bennett. Here. And Mayor Reynolds. Here. And Mayor Gould. Here. Thank you. We'll now move on to the speaker card announcement. Remote and speaker participation. If you are in person, you should first complete your speaker card found at the back of the chambers. Once completed, turn your cards into the city clerk and the speakers are taken in the order the cards received. In addition, citizens participating are now able to be a Zoom. Please note that if you wish to speak on Zoom, you will be asked to raise your hand when it's time for public comments on each specific item.
If not, no additional cards or Zoom speakers will be accepted. Persons demonstrating rude, boisterous behavior, speaking on matters outside the jurisdictional grounds of the City Council, or engaging in otherwise disruptive behavior will be called to order. If such conduct continues, we may call a recess or request removal of such persons. City Manager, can we have our closed session announcement? Yes, happy to provide that. So there were three items in closed session. The first item was a conversation with legal counsel on the Hall v. Chico case and direction was given to legal counsel on that item. The second item, the performance evaluation regarding the City Manager, actually was not complete and we'll resume that later this evening.
And after that is when I will report out if any action was taken on that item. And then the evaluation of City Clerk was where City Council discussed among themselves that particular matter. And that's their report from closed session. All right. Perfect, thank you. Consent agenda. All matters listed under the consent agenda are considered routine in nature and therefore can be enacted in one motion. Do we have any no votes or council disqualifications? No? Okay, I'll consider a motion. Motion to approve. Oh, hold on, I'm sorry. How many speakers do we have? We have one, Stephen Hazel. Stephen, okay. Thank you. My fellow 23 pair. Oh, no, you are. Remember, you're 23 pair chromosome. Let me explain.
You're like A&W root beer. You're 1 to 23. You're short XYZ, though, XYZ. You don't know where you are. You don't know why. Then you die. See, me and Jesus, I'm 126. My birthday's 12-6, actually, and the other guy's 6-12. I'm God. Here's my birth certificate. I was born in Berkeley, California. Mr. Hazel, this is on the consent agenda. I've described who I am. Excuse me. This is on the consent agenda. I've described who I am, okay? And I'm telling you to be you. See? Here it is. Be you. Don't be someone else, okay? Don't be a phony, okay? Don't posture. Don't get up there. And don't interrupt me either, okay? There's no crime committed. And don't pull this garbage on me, Mayor. That's why you're not elected.
That's why you were elected. This has no relationship with consent agenda. So I am talking right now, and I'm talking on the campaign. The reason why we're in this trouble is, ultimately, you're looking for someone to blame. If you want someone to blame... If you want to talk on camping, that's on a different agenda item, and you'll have to... No, no, no. This is on consent agenda. Yes, consent. And it's about camping, right? The orders. No, it's not. 2.1. Yeah, it is. 2.1 is consent, right? Okay. That's what I'm talking about. So what do you... Okay, can I have extra time? Because you're interrupting me. About another 30 seconds? Okay, I'll take it. So what happens is, you want to look for someone to blame?
You know who it is? You got to put your party aside, because you guys are divided. That's why we did a 5-2 flip. We liked the way it was going, okay? And so the whole thing about the homeless is a big issue in this town. Where's our governor? Where's the guy? You want to blame somebody? You can blame him and the previous guy, Brown, for causing all those problems, the homeless and everything. He's over in Ukraine? What's over in Ukraine? They say he's possibly the president. Come on. The guy who pardoned all these people. What is that? He's not even a person. That's ridiculous. What kind of person does that? Okay? So, and when you talk about the problem, you guys, great. Okay? You don't want Campy.
I was a Boy Scout. I don't just throw myself in there and just out everybody. Well, where are they going to go? See, of course, you can go downtown. You got a place to go. It's called home. They don't have a home. Okay? Of course, you don't want to support these guys for the rest of their lives. But there's the guy that just came before you, the church guy? There's your money. The church. Actually, the Mormon church. On behalf of my son. You know, they've collected over $300 billion, the Mormon church. Check it out. 5-14-2023, Mormon church. 60-minute piece. Chris Waddle. One of the three bishops. You got $300 billion right now for the second of Jesus. Okay? You're talking about taxing the rich.
I've been paid. There it is right there. I'll tell you, there's the money for the homeless. I got a tiny hometown in Chico, tiny houses by Bob Burhardt at the Valley Edge. Okay? There's land and everything for having a little place out there. So I don't want to turn Church Park into a tiny home. Like the chief said. He said two. She said four. All right. That's time. Thank you. You were going to give me extra time for interrupting me, right? That's time. Thank you. Okay. All right. We have a motion to approve. Do I have a second? Second. I'm sorry. I didn't hear the. So I made the motion before we wait. Speakers. It's not coming up. Okay. And that I'm sorry. My system is not working correctly.
It was a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda as read, which included ordinance of the city of Chico, amending title nine of the city of Chico municipal code to regulate certain acts of camping on public property. Final reading and adoption. Council member Goldstein. Yes. Let me see. Council member Holly. Yes. Council member O'Brien. Yes. Council member van over back. Yes. Council member Winslow. Yes. Vice mayor Bennett. Yes. Mayor Reynolds. Hi. Carrie seven zero. All right. Public comment members may address the council at this time on any matter that is not already listed on the agenda and that are within the jurisdictional authority. For those of you who are participating via zoom, please raise your hand.
If you would like to speak now, Please note that council cannot take any action at this meeting on these requests made under this section of the agenda. How many speakers do we have? I show eight and then. Checking on zoom. Okay. But we'll start with the eight. Okay. We have eight and if I'll call the first three and if you could line up, please, that would be great. Okay. So we have. We have Vic S. Followed by Ben. G. And then Kim deeds. So Vic is first. Hello, my name is Vic. I would like to congratulate the city council members on being elected in early November. Please note. I was in Palmetto when my car was hit by a person who did not stop at the stop sign. On her. She was texting. Hit my car and totaled it.
I would encourage several speed bumps and white stripes on Sheridan Avenue between Palmetto and first Avenue to get drivers to slow down. Once again, I am encouraging the city council to please install red light cameras on Palmetto and Sheridan Avenue. There are several hundreds of cars going to and from every single day. I count them at different times. I've counted them. Red light cameras would generate monies from drivers who are spinning down, speeding down Sheridan Avenue and Palmetto police officers should use professionalism and not indicate who these drivers are as well as not including their license plates. These monies would generally. Pay for these speed light cameras. Red light cameras.
I would also mention the street Macy off of Palmetto. And I walked my dog at least three times a day, different times and have witnessed the majority of drivers do not come to a stop. And roll through recently last week, a driver who did not stop almost hit me. And I fell down to the payment. Please be proactive and do something. A good friend of mine, his name is Ben. And he lives on Palmetto across from Macy. Street and has witnessed every day. Cars speeding 50 to 60 miles per hour and worse in the afternoon between two to 6 PM. Vehicle speed routinely between McDonald's and first stop sign on Sheridan Avenue. No, this happened because many people avoid first Avenue. He would also encourage the city to implement a stop sign at Macy street and Palmetto as was encouraged by Addison Winslow.
Thank you for your time. Thank you. So Benji and then followed by Kim Dietz. And then Bo Powell. Do we have a Benji? I see Bo coming. Okay. Kim Dietz followed by Bo Powell and then Kevin Walters. And if you could go ahead and line up, that would be great. Thank you. Hello. My name is Kim Dietz and I have lived in Chico since 1982. Last month. I informed the city council that I have founded. The Valen Brosia Avenue coalition. A nonpartisan forum that advocates for neighborhood interest before the city council and local government. As founder, I monitor relative city initiatives and keep residents informed about issues and developments affecting Valen Brosia Avenue. I've been a member of the Valen Brosia Avenue coalition for many years.
I've been a member of the Valen Brosia Avenue coalition. support an issue, we may provide public comment. The coalition is currently focused on two issues, the safety and anti-camping ordinances in Bidwell Park and the 2028 road rehabilitation project on Valenbridge Avenue. Last month I sent letters inviting all single-family property owners and occupants on Valenbridge Avenue to join the coalition. As of today, 26 residents have joined. That's about 25% of the letters that I sent out. I'm really pleased with this turnout which will lend credibility when we have an issue that comes before you. I also want the Valenbridge Avenue residents to know their City Council members, so in the future we hope to build a positive relationship with all of you. A few facts about Valenbridge Avenue. There are approximately 110 single-family residents on our street and 94 condominiums. The street is about three miles from Mangrove all the way down to Manzanita Avenue. It's odd that we're separated into four different districts, so we've got different districts all along the street. District 2 has about 12 properties. District 3, Mr. Bennett and Casey, Dale Bennett, District 3, we have about 30 properties. Can't read my own writing. District 4, 23 properties. Addison, you also have about 94 condominiums. I did not reach out to the condominiums yet but they're next. And then District 7, Bryce, you have about 42 properties. So look forward to it. Just wanted to let you guys know what's happening. It's part of my civic duty to get involved and I think this is gonna be a great way for us to communicate with you. Thank you. Thank you.
Bo Powell followed by Kevin Walters and then Steven Hazel. Hello again. Like I told you last meeting, I had talked to Bella Barbosa back there from Action News after to let Hayley Watts know that I was calling and what I was calling about. At that time Action News had said on the news that the FDA and the EPA had okayed a new agricultural chemical with forever chemicals in it and that it was going to be used in the Butte County orchards. That was it. Kind of under her breath. I wonder what would happen if the parents at Action News gave a crap about their viewers, about the people who risked their lives to protect them. They spray all of our children as we go down the road. Butte County legalized, after legalizing spraying 25 foot back on their property, they legalized spraying within 12 hours, 25 feet of a school. Those sprayers go 300 feet. In fact, California changed the setback to 400 feet. Our new congressman, when I talked to him about it, he said, how did Butte County override the state law? I said, I don't know. But they did it with the blessing of this council, the councils that came before it, the county supervisors, the child protection agencies, the police unions, the fire unions, all of them said nothing, say nothing. Rather than being held accountable for it, maybe we should think about taking this opportunity to have the county relook at the setbacks with these forever chemicals. I came here and I told you about the new Farm Bureau building. They had our senator out there and making a monkey out of him. I came here and held up his phone number, so you could call him and say something if you wanted to. Did any of you? I highly doubt it. I mean, if you're a public employee, like Mr. O'Brien there, 20 years they've been spraying illegally.
They sprayed illegally until they made it legal. Thank you. Thank you, Kevin Walters, followed by Stephen Hazel and then Noah Stone. Yeah, they should do away with all pesticides and all chemtrails. I mean, it's 40 different chemicals. Half of them are heavy metals, lead, strontium, bronium, and aluminum oxide, which is making everything more combustible, making everything more rustable. You know, since we're being sprayed with all these chemicals and all these pesticides, the forever chemicals in our food and stuff, you know, let's do away with smogging. Let's do away with smogging and registration. This is a ten-cent sticker that's hundreds and thousands of dollars now to get to put on your car, like it's some kind of privilege to drive. It's not a privilege to drive, it's a necessity of life, especially if you live out in Durham or something. You know, what else is a necessity of life? Food. Our president and Benjamin Netanyahu said that food is not a necessity of life. I mean, this is the idiocracy that we're living in. We're being sprayed with chemicals. Our food is all being sprayed with chemicals. Every single food supply and water supply has been poisoned now, even bottled water supply, with over 61,000 nanoparticles found on top of Mount Shasta. This is all factual stuff. There are states that have stopped it. Florida has stopped chemtrails and they're charging the pilots $100,000 to stop it. Fluoride has stopped being in the water in another state. Fluoride and there's better solutions. A copper containment, a three-stage water filter, a light that kills E. coli and a bacteria are better solutions than putting chemicals in your water that destroy your penile gland and calcify your penile gland and make you sick. And people are dying from the chemtrails. People with asthma. People have died from it. I have a friend that just died recently, 48 years old. This is what it is. You know, the Jetsons existed the same time as the Flintstones. We're the Flintstones. They're the Jetsons.
They all want to murder us now. That's what's going on. It's extermination. COVID, when it runs its course, because you guys aren't removing it from the hospitals or the clinics, is gonna kill more than half the population. It's already killed 12 million. It's gonna kill 5 billion. And then the neutron bombs from the data centers, which is a closed loop from water so they don't need any other water. They could have AWGs, asthmatic water generators, for mining and for data centers. They don't need to use any water of our drinking water. It's time. Thank you. I'm not done yet. I'm sorry. We'll be back in two weeks. So, yeah, that's your time. Thank you. I just want to say one more thing. 47. Sir, you're interrupting a public meeting. You've had your three minutes. Listen to this real quick. I understand, Mr. Walters. 1947 was the CIA. 1948 was Israel.
Says your second warning. 1949 is Mossad. Sergeant of Arms. If you want to arrest anybody or remove anybody, it should be you people. Murder. This is murder that's being committed. You get three minutes. You've had your three minutes. You're interrupting a public meeting. And with COVID, it's murdering. All right, Ms. Pressen. Thank you. Okay, Steven Hazel followed by Noah Stone and then Anika Rodriguez. I tell some people they wouldn't know if God was standing right in front of them. I'm standing right in front of you. Not who or what you expected. Hey, here's my birth certificate. I was born 12-6, 1959. I was born at night. I wasn't born yesterday. 1109 at night I was. My father was born December 7th. He was. And you know what? He died on August 6th in 66.
I was six years old. I vowed I'd get that guy. And I did with sidewalk chalk, according to Gary Laguna. He swore to me. And you know what? I put the fire out. The fire was supposed to burn to the 30th. On Friday, it was paradise. But no, Bush died on Friday, six days before my birthday. I got him. Six days before, I buried him on the 6th, six feet under. That's my story. And again, I'm with others matter. See my car? This Avalon? Remember I reported stolen when I was at Taurus. My shelter, your finest Taurus shelter, which is good. I gave a shout out. But then for some reason, someone tried to buzz me with three, I don't know, I'll just leave it at that. The license plate says, dog, my, D-O-G-M-A-I. But it's a personal. I see there's a little Stoopie.
Can't see it, but it's a little dog, Stoopie dog. My license plate frame says John 316. Says it all. The front says USA and God we trust. But for some reason it came up. It was a storm. It came to my apartment at apartment 217. Mayor, is that your birthday? Because at Jarvis Gardens, he said, we found your car. I go, cool. But there's a problem. He goes, it came up hot, but they let someone register. I go, what? And someone has an organ. What is that? What? Someone's got my car. What is that? What world are we living in? Chief, does that happen? Yeah, because I almost made it home once from King City. I got to the corner of Diablo and Walnut Creek and South California, North California. There's two lanes to turn. I was in the outside lane.
A car just ran and it bounced. I pulled up. I go, uh oh, there's a cop up there. What happened was, no damage to my car. Their car was towed like a snow plow. And they wouldn't let me see the guy's license. Does that happen, Chief? In an accident, they wouldn't let me see the guy's license. Whoa, is that weird? Tried to ram my car. It bounced off. It's not alive. See that car? I'm still looking for it. Anybody got a lawyer? Because, and they come around and do this thing every year. I got three of them. It's called A2L for positioning through the Highway Patrol. This guy named Mitch, I'm going to put her a shout out. She does this class. It's like drivers, like when you go to driver school. I got three of them for the last three years.
And I'm looking at my car because you get a discount once you get your, on your insurance. Her name's Mitch. She works for the Highway Patrol. And it's really good. It gives you like a refresher. The way you guys drive, I mean, it's crazy. Why don't you tell me? It's time, thank you. But other than that, okay, I'm done. That's time, thank you. So Noah Stone, followed by Anika Rodriguez. If you see that car, let me know. That's time, Mr. Hazel. Thank you. Do we have a Noah?
Go ahead, Noah. Thank you. Disciplinary action for people with medical and judicial needs mentioned in the new ordinance. That's illegal and a violation of human rights. And literally you're telling people they're not allowed to exist. In addition, you're doing illegal sweeps of camps right before the war and settlement ends, violating the war and settlement and setting yourself up for another settlement. They've literally illegally sweeps multiple different people's camps. You're literally displacing the vulnerable, refusing to help them. Then you refuse to provide them with the resources you're legally required to get them off their feet. Then you criminalize them and attack them and blame them for the issues you've created.
And then the money that meant for them, you spend attacking them and the rest just disappears. And I was raised Jewish. I'm part of this community doing community help and everything else and taught all about the Holocaust and being told never again. And now I'm sitting here watching people try and reason or rationalize, telling people they're not allowed to exist. And where's the morals and backbone? How are people going to try and rationalize telling someone else they're not allowed to exist? How are they going to openly break the law and then just not have any accountability? We need to have accountability, have these people held accountable and come together to build the town we want, rooting out the corruption and rebuilding the community ourselves.
Because clearly they're not doing this job and they're not going to. So I'm going to do it myself. You can check out my YouTube and my Facebook. My Facebook is Noah Stone. My YouTube is Noah Stone 420. I have all the evidence on it. I've opened federal cases against them. And I've literally have had numerous different agencies refuse to accommodate my disabilities, harass me and intimidate me. I had somebody claiming to be a city official telling me how I'm worthless and should just die and not exist. And I had other people retaliate against me, refusing to provide me with my medical needs and APS. I've had city officials refuse to respond to any of this when they're legally required to or accommodate my disabilities, violations of disability rights, just on and on and on.
And I watched this happening with my friends as well. They're breaking the law and they need to be held accountable. And it's wrong what they're doing. I've watched them fucking destroy the community and spirit of Chico since I was a child. Honestly, I think I got my points across. Thank you, Anika Rodriguez. Hi, you guys. I just wanted to say thank you for your continued support of downtown. Normally, I come to you tonight and ask you guys for free parking Friday. But last year, you passed it so that it just always happens. So not this Friday, but the following Friday, free parking Friday starts downtown through the end of December. But I also wanted to tell you that Pink Friday started last year.
It continues this year for our second annual Pink Friday event downtown. It's this coming Friday, the 20th. And last year, you guys really supported that initiative and it made a huge difference for the downtown shops. And I just wanted to say thank you for your continued support. I have enjoyed working with every single one of you guys on council on different initiatives. And I am just thank you for everything you're doing for downtown. I'm so happy to see hope is returning. Thank you. Let's not share. We want everybody to feel welcome and happy to speak here. Thank you. She was our last speaker. All right. Item 4.1 confirmation of deputy fire chief. We have a report from our city manager, Gillian.
I'm going to pass this over to our administrative services director, Barbara Martin. All right. Thank you. Good evening, Mayor, Vice Mayor, members of council. Per the government code, we have a contract for the deputy fire chief. And in compliance with the government code section five, four, nine, five, three, C3, the city manager shall first orally report a summary of the recommendation for final action related to the deputy chief fire employment agreement as follows. City manager is proposing to enter into an employment agreement with Philip Stelle as the deputy fire chief and the city manager is proposing to appoint Mr. Stel with an annual salary of one hundred eighty five thousand dollars.
And also the city manager recommends city council confirmation of the employment of Philip Stelle as the deputy chief fire. Take any questions. All right. Any questions? Do we have any speakers? We do. One, Stephen Hazel.
I get three minutes, a whole three minutes. Wow. You know what? We should have three minutes to my what? Let's do 50 speakers. That's it. It's three minutes. But anything over 50, then get it to two. But when you turn to say, Debbie, I know I'm not upset because I'm talking about the time. I'm using my time wisely because you'd say one minute. There's no way in the world anybody would ever get one minute. If it's why we would rather come to two minutes about one minute should never occur. OK, no matter what. So that's just. the new mayor does that. Maybe he will. Get it? He will. He's a woman, can't be president or mayor. You can't be. It's just that's it. It's just that's all. Because I'm gonna protect you. Okay, what it is, you know, with the fire chief, he's just one step from the top. So, you think of fire chief, well, you're looking wrong because, well, you see the fire truck go. You're not going to a fire. Fire is maybe one out of 100, maybe, right? Maybe one out of 100 calls it's a fire. And all these other calls. And what I'm saying is, I live at the corner, a Jarvis car, nice apartment complex, but it's a really dangerous intersection. And he would know because we've had some major accidents. And I showed you that class I took about, you know, major comes around, does that, drive safe, you know, for the, we try to keep everybody safe. And what happens is, I swear, every time we come, there's a major accident. And she comes and gives this class about drive safe and stuff like that. What happens is, the fire department is always there first. They're there before anybody, you know. So, it's important because at that intersection, it's always coming east. For some reason, there's two signs there.
There's a temporary sign, they need to go. There's one, a Harris sign, it's a contract, whatever, like a green sign. Then there's Hanush. You got a permit, but they have a wind sign. Both those signs obstruct the view right there. It's like your tunnel vision. And what happens is, there was a guy running for all different reasons. And here's the fire department now. They got to come down where, I like to then be main time repairman. Remember when the fire chief was named? I go, hey, I would rather he be, he doesn't do nothing. Because I hate, those guys are coming out always on calls. And they're nice, you know, to turn down the siren because they're coming by the senior citizen place. But, I mean, it gets loud sometimes. But they're always coming down. And right at that intersection, it's really bad. But, see, this whole thing, that's what I really want to point out, was the actions there. And it's more than just fires. If you think about it, these guys, and I was going to say too, when you said half our budget, you don't even consider how much do they cost us to the budget, you say the police are half of the budget, we don't have any money coming in.
And we need more fire department, but you want more housing, more housing. That's more, put more strain on him. He's got to now, all this, everything, it puts more work on this guy. So be careful when you start building, you think housing is the answer. That's time, thank you. Housing isn't the answer. Is that our only speaker, Mrs. Presson? Just put a lot more work for him. I'm assuming. Motion move to approve? I'll second that. Thank you.
Council Member Goldstein? Yes. Council Member Hawley? Yes. Council Member O'Brien? Yes. Council Member van Overbeek? Heck yeah. Council Member Winslow? Yes. Vice Mayor Bennett? Yes. Mayor Reynolds? Aye. Carries 7-0. We will now move to the next agenda and item 4.3 and 4.4 are going to be heard together. So City Manager, I will take a report from City Manager Haen.
Thank you. I'm doing my favorite thing on my birthday, presenting at City Council. Thank you for hearing this item this evening, Council, and thank you community members for all showing up and being here to be part of the process. It's important that you're here. So I'm going to hand it over to Erik. He's going to start us off with some background and then we're going to get into the plan itself. But I just want to reiterate, this plan is driven by the community input that's been gathered over the last month. It's a starting point. It's a living document. It's not a perfect document because those don't exist for this issue of the unhoused in our community. There is no silver bullet solution and each human is very different.
And so we have to use different strategies and different approaches with different people. So this plan is just a first draft of measures to move forward that we are planning on monitoring, measuring, and adjusting as needed. Whatever works, we'll do more of. Whatever doesn't work, we'll do less of. If new creative ideas come along the way, we'll consider those as well. So this isn't a regulatory document. It's a guidance document. It's a roadmap to start something because there's a lot of work to be done in this area. So thank you for hearing us this evening. I'm going to pass it to Erik to start our background and then I'll come back and review the individual strategies. Thank you, City Manager Haen, Mayor and Council.
Pleasure to speak to you tonight. Thank you. For your presentation to get through, I'm going to touch on the background and kind of the outline of the presentation overview, and then we'll hand it over to City Manager Haen to dive into the goals and action items of the plan. So quick overview, brief background. I'm going to jump into the plan, look at the goals, objectives, action items. There's a slide on an encampment cleanup protocol. That's kind of a process that we'll look at as well. We really took a lot of public feedback and input on this item. We had a handful of meetings. We'll touch on those and added some of that feedback already to the plan as an update that we'll present to you.
How we intend to implement the plan, and then we'll land on a staff recommendation slide. As a background, as you all know, the settlement agreement Warren versus City of Chico started January 14th, 2022. Five-year term ends on January 14th, 27, which is right around the corner. It required us to construct and open an emergency shelter known as Genesis. It allowed us to use the tourist shelter as an additional sheltering option, and that was kind of one of the frustrating pieces of the settlement agreement, is it really limited us to only shelter capacity in both Genesis and Torres. There was a handful of other shelter service providers in town, and we were not able to use those facilities in our counts and our enforcement operations, which was always frustrating.
We had to open up the alternate site. As you all know, that was kind of an 11th hour item, a bit of a surprise to all of us towards the end of the negotiations. It's been difficult to manage, but it's there. We have it down to about five people that are there, and we'll continue to work on those five, get them into some sort of transitional housing before the settlement agreement ends. As you know, our intent is to close the alternate site rather quickly after the settlement agreement terms. We also were tasked with individual assessments with multiple documented attempts to offer shelter. So during the notification period, the last phase of the notification period, as you all know, we have to make five attempts to try to contact those individuals and get them into a sheltering option.
So pretty heavy workload on the outreach and engagement side. And then, of course, the 17 day notification period before an enforcement encampment cleanup can begin. And that's pretty limiting. 17 days is a long time and really limits the number of enforcements or cleanups or opportunities that we could get folks into shelter as we move along because of that notification requirement. So after expiration of Warren, the city will no longer be bound by those specific settlement agreement requirements, and we will regain full discretion on how to address encampments and enforce muni code provisions. And this is primarily due to the Supreme Court's June of 2024 decision in the Grants Pass versus Johnson case, which reversed the 18 decision of Martin versus Boise that we were all under in the ninth district.
To really kind of reflect and look back at council direction from May, which these were really our short term goals or initiatives that we started on, we received unanimous unanimous support from council again to close the alternate site on expiration of the settlement agreement. Staff has always felt that there's still a need for emergency shelter opportunity, and so we wanted to continue to keep Genesis open and operational. You directed us to continue the pursuit of grant funding to offset Genesis costs. We've been pretty successful with offsetting Genesis costs in the last few years and want to continue that initiative and really try hard to search for and be successful with grants. City attorneys bringing muni code recommendations forward as we speak.
We did ask council to approve a kind of a phase enforcement strategy, beginning in the center of the city, working outwardly and continue using the O and E model. And then also, this is ongoing directing staff to identify kind of a high utilizer service resistant team to address those that continue to refuse services or sheltering opportunities that we're providing them. So why draft an unhoused strategic plan again, those initiatives that were passed in May are really this shorter term objectives, if you will, we wanted to really create a clear and longer term road map beyond those six initiatives moving into the next few years. Understand public sentiments of all affected community members. Of course, you know, it's this is a very complex issue. We're not going to solve it on our own.
And we wanted to cast a wide net to really capture all of the input and impacts that different sectors of the community are dealing with and that are dealt with. And we wanted to take that all into consideration. We want to encourage collaborative solutions for the issues at hand. We want to reduce duplication, manage expectations and move from short term responses toward a new, more sustainable, measurable approach. You know, we're pretty fortunate to have a lot of service providers in Chico. Sometimes we all don't row in the same direction, but we want to do what we can to reduce duplication and give everybody everybody on the same page looking forward for a longer term strategy. We want to continue to balance compassion and accountability. I think we've done a pretty good job at that over the last five years, and we want to continue that initiative.
And again, the on how strategy will be our overarching plan for the next several years. Again, it's important to note that we cannot solve homelessness alone, but we do think we could lead a more coordinated response with our partners. Butte County shelter operators, health care providers, housing partners and community organizations, you know, the continuum of care does a lot of that work already that we really feel that the city could really take a leading role in those initiatives and make sure that, again, we're reducing duplication, managing expectations and moving from short term responses toward a new, more sustainable, measurable approach. Again, we're reducing duplication. Everybody's on the same page, and we're doing everything we possibly can to solve the issue on a local level.
There's a lot of, you know, county, state and federal initiatives, too, that we want to take advantage of when we can, you know, care, court, conservatorship, those types of things we really need to take a hard look at with our local partners when those opportunities arise. The plan emphasizes connecting individuals to appropriate services and stable housing, improving shelter effectiveness, addressing complex behavioral health needs and maintaining our public spaces for their intended use. I mean, everybody has, I think, compassion for folks that are dealing with homelessness, but also we have a duty to keep our public spaces free and clear for their intended use for all the citizenry of Chico.
So with that, I will give it back to City Manager Hange to start on the goals, and then she'll take a deep dive into the 18 action plans in the plan. Thank you, Erik. So in the plan, we identified several goals. We spoke to them, Erik spoke to them a little bit, leading a coordinated regional effort, improving our outreach, maintaining safe, healthy and accessible public spaces, preventing homelessness and increasing housing stability as we can, and coordinating the behavioral health and high utilizer interventions, and then measuring results and strengthening public accountability. Those are in no specific order. They're all just as important goals for the plan. Okay, got it. All right, so I'm going to jump into an explanation of the 18 plus one strategies proposed in the plan.
Because of some of the community feedback, portions of the plan were amended and adjusted, and we'll talk about those after we go through the strategies. So the first strategy is to, if the Council so chooses, adopt the plan, and then have an annual work plan for implementation, and that would be headed by the City Manager's Office in coordination with all the departments. The second strategy we're already working on, we've thus far, the Council has adopted three new ordinances in the last 90 days. And so that operational package of ordinance updates is one of our strategies to make sure that we have that strong legal, bless you, legal foundation for the process as we move forward. Without those ordinances, then it doesn't give a clear road path for the next steps in implementation of the plan.
The third item is to create and distribute educational materials about these changes in the law and the shelter and services that are available, the resources. This is where, when we met with the lived experience partners, I really thought it would be a great opportunity here to partner with people who have been homeless prior to do some of this coordination and outreach and education. And so it'd be, you know, in the next couple weeks, if Council approves this tonight, it'd be even before Warren expires, but just educating the homeless about the changes in the rules that are coming down the pipeline, so they're not hit suddenly and just sideswiped. That they know ahead of time, you know, four to six weeks ahead of time when the rules are going to change and what those changes look like. And then also being provided the services and shelter options in that timeline of the educational outreach.
Number four is transitioning and closing the alternative campsite out at Eaton and Cohasset Road. Next slide. Oh, that's me. The fifth strategy is to take a look at our partners, shelters, and service providers that receive city, state, or federal funding and giving like a mini audit on performance and looking at the contracts and looking at the requirements for participation and just making sure that the processes are streamlined and that they are as beneficial as possible moving forward. Six and seven are that regional coordination, just interagency collaboration and making sure that we're working with our mental health partners and our addiction partners and all of our service provision is included in our resources as we move forward and just that regional collaboration is super important.
Working together, as Erik mentioned, is more successful than working ourselves alone on the issue. Number eight is creating a reporting system for tracking and reporting any important housing or encampment issues or needs. So we're working in-house on this. It's really expensive to buy software, so we're working with our GIS analysts right now to develop a program internally. We're going to test it out here with our Public Works O&M reporting ticketing system and then also for the unhoused plan implementation. And if it works well, then we may bring it back citywide. This is something right now we just get homeless issues emailed to Public Works or people call police dispatch or even city manager's office and there's not one place that they all live.
And so this system, hopefully you'll be able to take your cell phone, take a photo, there's a person in the plaza that needs shelter, send it in and it can pin drop the location. You can enter your name if you'd like follow up and then there's a report back structure where the communication is closed full loop. So I think this will be a really great program to implement moving forward. A-9 is adopt a citywide encampment response protocol, name that task force to implement. This is an operational function. And usually in this type of process, we don't kind of daylight city operations that remains in the city manager's office as a responsibility. But I knew that through the feedback that I've been gathering from the public in the last three months that people are really interested in how does this work?
What does that 48 hour notice look like? So after we go through these strategies, we'll walk you through that 48 hour noticing process in those operations and who's involved with that. A-10 is mapping those priority sites. This will tie into that GIS reporting system and we'll be able to have a map. We'll be able to follow up and track where we've completed cleanups and where they're in process so that we can see our activity. And we can check back in seven days, 15 days, 30, 90, whatever timelines we want to ensure that places are remaining clean. And that wildfire risk areas are open and clear and our parks and our bike paths and all of the different areas on the map are clean and restored moving forward.
Number 11, I think it's really important for the transparency to the public and also for council decision making purposes to understand how much we're actually spending on homelessness in the city. Right now, for example, none of my time has been tracked that I've spent on this plan and this outreach and this very important issue. So moving forward, we're going to work with our administrative services director for a time card accounting of all staff within the city that works on any sort of homelessness issue at all so that we can track and manage and monitor that. It'll also give us the metrics for us to understand as we're tracking successful entrances into housing and encampment cleanups.
Then we can compare that to the staff time that we've used and the resources that we spent to get those successes moving forward. It'll help us with our future decisions. A12 is something that I worked on when I was living in Sonoma County. I did work in Santa Rosa, but when I was working in Vallejo living in Sonoma County, we had a program that was called a safe car parking, a roving shelter. And so all of the faith-based partners and churches in Santa Rosa would each sign up for a week, 52 weeks a year. And if someone was living in their car, they could have the schedule and the calendar of where to go for a safe place to park. And so the church would open their parking lot, security would be there, and a lot of amenities, showers, food, clothing.
We cooked a lot of meals for people, sat down, and I did homework with children, and just gave that safe place. Some sanctuaries opened where people could sleep inside and just park their car, and then some people just felt more comfortable in their cars, so they were able to just stay in their cars. That program was super successful, and so I really want to try and work with our partners here in Chico, because I know there's a lot of willing and able people that can help and want to be part of the solution, so I think this is a really good one, especially for those that are living in their cars but still working and living life, and they just need a little bit of extra support. This is a really great program.
Additional landlord engagement and flexible housing development funds. These are just strategies that support housing, and so, as we know, the Housing Authority of the County of Butte works on all of our HUD voucher programs, project-based vouchers and housing choice vouchers, and so just ensuring that we're working with them to encourage landlords to accept those vouchers is important for affordable housing options. And then the flexible housing development fund. We do have some community members that are interested in supporting housing development, especially for the permanent supportive area, arena, and so we really want to work on creating a fund so that we can pair up partners and grant funding and this specific benefactor fund to get the housing built that the city and the community needs.
Number 14 is create and implement a reunification plan. I've heard from many that this did used to exist in the city, but the opportunity is no longer here, so we're going to reignite this opportunity, and what this is is working with the homeless individual and finding out if they have a support system outside of Chico, helping them reunite with that friend or family. Maybe it's out of state. Maybe it's a few counties over, but there's a lot of success in people moving forward when they have a support system, and so if there are opportunities, this program would provide them a bus ticket, a plane ticket, food, travel, all of the things and support they need to get reunified to their support system.
And then A15 goes back to the reporting piece. It's a baseline dashboard that we would update quarterly online so the public and staff and council can follow tracking and monitor our progress. Those metrics are going to be very important as we move forward for decisions. A16, we currently contract with Safe Space to do extreme weather centers, but I was pretty surprised to hear that we don't do those year-round in Chico, so our winter cold weather centers open December 1st, and as we know, there's been some pretty aggressive rain this last week in pretty cold circumstances, so I really do want to take another look at those extreme weather centers and maybe see if there's any opportunity to expand them to be year-round.
I know that they do cost money, but there is definitely a need. When I started in August, I think they had ended and there were still several days over 100 degrees, so I think on the winter cold end and the summer hot end, the weather necessitates these weather centers for being open year-round, so I think we need to look at that, look at our potential grant funding and partners, and really, the numbers that Safe Space reported out are great, and I think that serving the most vulnerable community in this way is very important, so that's one of the strategies. Number 17, what happens when there's no beds left? So we've got transitional shelter, we've got emergency shelter, we've got supportive housing, we've got permanent, all of the different pipelines of housing for different people's needs, but what happens when all of our beds are filled and we don't have anywhere for people to go, but yet they're going to get a 48-hour notice with our new ordinance?
This is creating a program. I worked in Vallejo on the hotel voucher system program for a couple nights in a hotel to get people on their feet and figure out where their next spot to go is going to be, and we also worked with the mobile home park and got a few mobile home units. When there wasn't housing, we could house the individual in a mobile home for two, three nights until they could get on their feet and find their next plan for housing. So I think it's important for interim housing options to have those backup plans, and then 18 is, you know, return in the next year and do the same thing over, measure what's working, what's not working, and then create that work plan, adjust as needed, and move forward for year two.
We did add another one, but I'll talk about that after we talk about the protocol and the edits. So this is our review, our roadmap of our encampment protocol, and this just explains what happens with the 48-hour noticing and the new law. So first, the encampment's reported. Either someone uploads it on their cell phone or they give us a call and let us know there's a tent on the plaza and there's three people living in it. The police department intakes that, and all those logs will be tracked for processing. As the initial response goes out, we have our outreach coordinator, our target team, and we go out and we issue that 48-hour notice. We pair that with our list of resources. In between three and four is where we, you see the little yellow 48-hour notice sign, that area is where we partner with our community and our service providers, and we pair people with resources to help them comply or to find shelter or to find service or to find the motel program or to get into an emergency shelter, extreme weather center, whatever it is, we find them those resources as we can.
And then as the police follows up after the 48-hour notice, they would then verify that the encampment is cleared, they would handle any property that's left behind that needs to be dealt with, take enforcement action if needed, and then notify Public Works. And then step five would be the Public Works team comes out and removes any trash or debris that's left over and restores the site. So that's how the operational protocol works in a little roadmap for you all. At the bottom, you can see the six-month immediate action plan. We heard as we were floating this plan and gathering input that people really wanted to understand what happens in the first six months, what looks different, how will things move forward.
And so beginning, I say tomorrow, but that was maybe a little aggressive, maybe after Thanksgiving, if this is approved tonight, we'll be moving towards proactively conducting that outreach on those educational materials on the changed rules and timelines, and then also providing those resources. So end of November. And then pretty immediately, once January 15th hits, we will be working on restoring Eaton Cohasset Alternative Camping Site in Sycamore Creek and securing downtown plaza in the downtown areas, just as Council directed in their May 16th guidance. So those will be our very first priorities. And then the approach is to provide notice to as many unhoused individuals as possible for the first several weeks up to a couple months, starting January 15th.
So it's not going to be an approach of go down to the plaza and give three people a 48-hour notice, and go to the edge of downtown and give them a 48-hour notice, and then go up to Bidwell and give them a 48, and then come back around and do that. The approach would be to give as many notices as possible to everyone as possible, and then come back through strategically. We just don't have the staffing, and it would take hundreds of people to find all of our unhoused community members and immediately come back every single 48 hours. So what this does is kind of like an off-ramp in a transition period for the first round of noticing. The ordinance that was approved tonight is a one-person, one-notice.
So once people have been noticed within the city, that is their notification. So then we would come back strategically and work on the enforcement and cleanup thereafter. And then obviously the park areas are priority, and then we want to rotate through districts cleanups thereafter so that it's not just centralized in one area being cleaned up, but that it's just rotated throughout the city. So we did a lot of engagement and input gathering for this plan. October 27th, we had a service provider meeting. There was about 35 people in attendance. It was really, really helpful just listening to their input and gathering their comments. On November 4th, we did a community-wide town hall. There was over 100 people in this very room.
We presented that draft plan to residents, and we had 25 speakers and multiple written comment cards submitted, and it was very useful as well. We received a lot of feedback at that meeting. And then November 10th, we met with 12 or 13 lived experience individuals who have experienced homelessness prior to gather their perspectives and their input and recommendations, and that was very insightful. They actually really supported many aspects of the plan and wanted to be part of the solution. It was pretty inspiring to sit with them and hear the different stories and understand how using the resources effectively has really changed their lives. And some of them had to go through different resources and different places and locations and services because, again, all humans are different and not everyone responds the same to each opportunity they're given.
So it was really great to hear those stories and then just to hear that, how can we help? How can we help communicate? How can we tell our stories to others and try and help them get the services that they need? So that was really a meaningful meeting. We received over 60 emails at unhoused at ChicoCA.gov. We stood that email up to gather input through email. Today there was another about seven emails, so we have about 67 emails. And I had met between 15 and 20 people one-on-one that just wanted to talk about the plan, wanted to talk about the implementation, wanted to talk about their ideas and give me their thoughts one-on-one, which was really good. Some were just simple phone calls, but some were just in person and some were over coffee.
And it was just really great to hear those perspectives. And then as I met Farmers Market on a Saturday and someone tracks me down, I have those random conversations too. So many, many times throughout the city, I think we really got a good touch point and temperature from so many different groups of people on this plan, which I think makes it a better plan. So there are a few updates that were made to the plan based on that input, because we value our community and their thoughts and their priorities as well. So the biggest items that we changed in the plan were we shortened the timeline originally. The proposal was for a five-year plan, and we heard from people that they don't want a five-year plan.
They really would like to see something in a two- or three-year timeline. So we reduced the timeline to two years, because we can always extend that if we need to, can always add time if we need to. So we are now proposing a two-year timeline for this plan, and we are focusing that timeline on a shorter path. The goal initially for the unsheltered homelessness was to reduce it 25% during the plan period, which is five years. And we heard very loud and clear that that was too little and too long. So we upped that goal to a 50% reduction in our unsheltered community within the first two years. And that really is the pick count of the 380 unsheltered. It's not the larger number. So it's a reduction of that.
And then we added a strategy to address support of nonprofit and other partners. We heard a lot from housing advocates and service providers that the city isn't proposing managed campgrounds, the city isn't proposing tiny homes or day centers or other housing options city-sponsored, but that they really thought that those were some solutions that should be addressed. And so instead of just letting it be unspoken, we added a strategy that says we will research opportunities to support others, partners that want to develop some of these housing options. So I think it's important that we have that variety and we can support with grant funding applying together, we can support with helping them through any processes, we can support in many different ways.
And so I think it's important that we called that out in the plan. So moving from planning to action, what are our next steps? So tonight, council will hear our staff presentation, they will hear community, additional community input and feedback and consider the revisions that staff is proposing, may have some revisions of your own for us to consider. And if the plan is approved, we will then begin implementation and the plan itself and the ordinances will not be in effect until January 15th, but there's a lot, as I said, a lot of work to do leading up to that point on outreach and regional collaboration and coordination and developing different educational materials and getting all of our resources listed and partners on board.
And so there's a lot of work that needs to be done that we can start ahead of implementation on January 15th. And then moving forward, it's just really, really important to continue coordinating with our partners, mental health and addiction services, of course, are a large, large need and just creating that partnership with the county and leaning into them to help provide the services that they do provide for our residents here in Chico is really important. So that's going to be a big priority of ours as we move forward. And then tracking and sharing progress, that's also very important because we don't know what success looks like until we are able to measure and track and look at those metrics and understand what's working or what's not working and being flexible and adjusting the plan.
As I said earlier in the evening, it's a living document. It's not a regulatory document. It's a guiding document. Protocols can change and strategies can change and new ideas can come to fruition and new partnerships can happen. And we wrote the plan in such a way that any of those, you know, smaller, non-substantive changes can happen at the city manager and staff level and anything that's a very large issue then would come back for a plan amendment to council if needed. And then our proposal is to come back in six months so that we have a little bit of time to start implementation and then report back to council on our progress and if we have any recommended adjustments at that time bringing them to city council for your consideration but giving us that six months to get the GIS reporting system in place and the outreach done and, you know, just get things starting to move and then come back to you in six months.
And then again at 12 months. So that is the proposal there on reporting back. In addition, this evening, the second item behind this item is a staffing request for funding. We have a very limited team right now. I think I've told all of you in Vallejo I had a huge homeless team behind me implementing all of this and here we have me and Erik and part of every one of your directors. So we definitely need a little bit of an augmentation for this first round of implementing. And so we're asking for use of our opioid fund settlement fund so that it doesn't touch the general fund. These funds are appropriate for the use. So we are asking for $300,000, $100,000 for PD staffing and overtime and $200,000 for operations and maintenance so we can do some contracting with cleanup services to move forward with some of the restoration and potential outreach and things of that nature.
So that $300,000 is just a guess. We got some estimates and we may not need it all. We may need more. We don't know yet until we start implementing. So that's part of that reporting back system and just letting you know where we are and what progress we're making for what degree. So this is the request that we have as far as funding to ensure that we're successful because no plan is a good plan if it just sits on the shelf and doesn't get implemented. But also I don't want to over promise and under deliver because I think it's important that the expectation from community is that we're going to see a physical change in our environment here in the city and we want to be able to provide that action and implementation Without doing that, you know, we would be looking at if we don't want to spend the opioid settlement funds, we would be looking at using our existing target team on a three per month basis cleanup is kind of what we were currently working and people will be part of the target team and do that cleanup and then go back to the tree trimming or the leaf pickup or whatever it is that they're working on.
And so it's just a part time and it will be a much more slower moving process if we do not augment with some staff and some consultant assistance. So that is our professional recommendation moving forward that we meet the community expectations and move forward with a good shot in the arm for that first six months so that we're ensuring our successful implementation. So with that, city managers recommending that council adopt the resolution and approve the unhoused strategic plan for implementation and approve the use of the opioid settlement funding totaling $300,000 for plan implementation and those are two separate resolutions for your consideration tonight. So I just want to clarify that.
Thank you so much for your time. All right. Thank you. Questions? Okay. Council Member Hawley. Thank you, Ms. Haen and Mr. Gustafson. I was so sad to miss the community meeting because that pesky Vina GSA board meeting, but I only heard amazing things from our community members. Especially excited about A12, that roving safe car parking shelter program. I think that's something Ms. Haen and I discussed in our first meeting together and it's very exciting to see that as a tangible, actionable item within this plan. Just because I wasn't at that community meeting and I didn't hear it explicitly stated, I do have a question on the reunification plan and how that program will materialize. I'm curious if that would include travel.
to support systems within Chico or do we anticipate that just being outside of Chico and Butte County? And if I'm asking too specific questions already that's okay we can address that in a couple of months. No worries happy to talk to you about how we envision it working because you're right this is a high-level plan and so some of the details on these programs have yet to be developed and we'll be working with our community and partners to do so but normally it's not within the city of Chico normally we already have other resources that we can tap into for that but the reunification plan would be external outside of the city of Chico that specific plan and so working on the funding for those assistances would be outside and then if there's something that's internal we would work on our community partners here and tap into those for the internal if someone needs you know just to be driven or bust or you know taken somewhere across town or great thank you councilmember Goldstein first of all thank you Gillian and Erik for that great presentation I just had one quick question on the opioid settlement funds can you refresh me on how long we have to spend these funds if that is the total amount that we're allocated or if this is like a yearly funding source and what else we or other cities normally spend them on I just want to make sure we're making the best choice of how to spend them not saying I have any problem with it yes thank you for that question I'm gonna punt to Barbara for a second but I will tell you in Vallejo we spend a large amount of those funds on homeless services on housing on permanent supportive housing projects anything related with mental health or addiction services is a allowable spend for those funds and I'll let Barbara give you the numbers on totals and whatnot thank you yes the opioid settlement funds we will be getting them yearly until the mid 2030s many drug companies were part of this settlement agreement because of the opioid epidemic we are getting anywhere between 200 and up to over 500,000 depending on what year and how much was settled with the different companies so we will be getting an on an ongoing source of revenue and it's very specific to this opioid mitigation cause so we can't just use it for general fund purposes or for other enforcement or anything like that we have to use it for very specific reasons outlined in the settlement great thank you so much that's all from me all right I don't see anybody else in the queue how many speakers do we have we have 14 all right two minutes each two minutes okay so I'm gonna call the first three names and if you could please line up that will expedite a little bit Molly Copta Linda Zorn and Pamela Sage so it's Molly Copta Linda Zorn Pamela Sage
sorry good evening members of City Council and city staff thank you to all of you for the transparency throughout this early phase of the strategic or unhoused strategic plan creation throughout this process staff has provided timely information solicited feedback demonstrated a willingness to incorporate that feedback into this plan and continued to make adjustments up until I believe a few hours ago this plan outlines near and long-term considerations to address factors associated with homelessness establishes frameworks for open communication and visibility into the process and invites the community to actively participate towards solutions compassion and accountability are not mutually exclusive and this understanding permeates throughout each of the now 19 points outlined in this plan on behalf of the Chico Chamber of Commerce we express our support for this plan and request council adopt the strategic unhoused plan as it is written thank you thank you Linda Zorn followed by Pamela Sage and then Brandon Slater good evening Mayor Reynolds council members and city staff my name is Linda Zorn I'm a board member of the downtown Chico Business Association my comments are in support of the direction of the draft unhoused strategic plan thanks to all of you and city staff for the hard work behind it the plan strikes the right balance between enforcement and compassion and if approved and implemented will help all Chico businesses especially those located in downtown it's not perfect but we have to start somewhere I appreciate the city's commitment to a lawful compassionate and accountable approach I ask that you vote yes to adopt the resolution and approve this plan a yes vote reflects your support for our Chico business community thank you for the opportunity to provide input thank you so Pamela Sage Brandon Slater and Mike Troll under good evening thank you so much for the opportunity to address you tonight I think your plan is really good I think what's really missing here is a long-term mental health facility I have a well I had a sister that lived on the streets for about three decades she died about 20 years ago in her early 50s drug-addicted I have a niece that's been on the streets now in Reno for a number of decades and what's missing in so many of the rehab programs people and I just want to say that a huge percentage of the homeless population are ex-foster children the majority of our most violent prisoners in our prisons are ex foster children and a lot of these people these kids in foster care they're moved from home to home to home to home all they know is whoever's providing that household is making a lot of money and a lot of it's not being spent on them and to be moved and moved and moved and moved a lot of these people do not trust the government they do not trust these programs so sometimes the most serious mentally ill that's on the streets I think that they need to be compelled to go into a long-term thing I have a interdisciplinary masters at Chico State I wrote a mental health program in my thesis I'd like to share with you in the future and I just think that if we had a big enough place with your acreage where we could grow animals they could grow food they could be participating because one of the most important flyers I ever got in my education first week of school was the way out of madness meaningful work we can't put these people in a room and start giving them meds and say okay you're a couple days okay you're good now go on home they need a detox place where they can safely and I'm okay thank you thank you very much thank you Brandon please go ahead and email that over and we'll Mike Trillander and Adam Fidelity good evening counselors and staff Brandon Slater Chico Chamber of Commerce just come in here today to express our support for the plan overall we've sent some some comments but overall as it is I think it as we kind of understand that it's really not the specifics and it's just the overall plan we've talked to a lot of people and feel like there's a pretty good balance between the compassion side and the enforcement side your equal number of complaints from both sides as well I I personally think that that we should be celebrating all of the progress we've made over the last five years just as far as the amount of good that we've done and folks that we've helped so I think that's good I think that we do need to think about long-term plan for for Genesis those those structures are not constructed in a way that are gonna last for forever so we need to start thinking about that before they fall apart but overall I'm hoping I challenge y'all to a 7-0 vote here would be pretty cool and we can all start rowing the boat in the same direction so thanks everybody thank you Mike troll under Adam Fidelity and then Tammy Ritter hello council my name is Mike trolling der I'm not a writer or speaker but I am and so I approach this through the work of an urbanist which is getting the human condition and the built environment to work together in that equation nobody's left out but I would like to say a couple things Tom you're right no camping is where we need to be how do we get there that's where you're not right but you're absolutely right no camping is what we need and I'm still mad at you I met with sea manager and Erik I they're the best team we've ever had you cannot I mean I we have studied a lot of cities you cannot do better mistakes fully made they'll be owned but this is the right team here are my words for tonight I can't even see him tonight I come before you with a prayer how much more can we lose so you can balance the city's books you reduced our suffering joint accounting problem you bankrupted our trust in you and in each other you did that who are you serving that's time mr. troll under I'm sorry you are the people so thank you thank you I know Adam Fidelity Tammy Ritter followed by Katie Toma evening council mayor Reynolds members of council thanks for serving as always so you've heard me speak on this topic before so I'm going to reiterate a couple points that I've made over the years first of all I would encourage an abundance of caution as we roll this out we want to make sure we don't end up where we've just been so an abundance of caution second creativity especially on the housing side of things in terms of what we can do as a bureaucracy and a governing entity to just speed things along there is state law as my friend Charles has mentioned many times that we could take advantage of that I don't know that we have yet but fundamentally if we're gonna solve this with the reasonable expectation of our public places being free of debris pollution and broken folks is there has to be a place where people can go I'd recommend four places in the four quadrants of the city there needs to be a place where people can go even it's just for the day to get situated and that get channeled to where they need to be that's crucial and I didn't see anything in the game plan that mentioned trying to identify places where we could tell people okay you can't be there go be there and then we'll take it from there and move on the process so those are my thoughts thanks all very much thank you Tammy Ritter followed by Katie Toma and then Stephen Hazel honorable counsel I'm gonna talk fast my name is Tammy Ritter I represent the third district of the Butte County Board of Supervisors I recognize that you cannot answer my questions but I'm going to pose them your strategic plan states it is designed to thoughtfully guide policy partnership and budget following the settlement agreement your draft plan says you consulted with countless service providers community partners and Chico residents you include in your description that you worked with quote partnerships across the Butte County continuum of care the very first goal listed in your strategic plan is to lead a coordinated regional system like the continuum of care what do you mean by aligned resources with the COC the city of Chico holds two voting membership positions on the COC I'm not sure how much more aligned you can get goal four states you will prevent homelessness and increase housing stability it states you will target flexible prevention does the city plan to make resources available for direct cash grants for paying rental arrears or resolving outstanding medical bills the county and multiple local agencies of the COC are already providing housing navigation and support additionally other flexible prevention is a CHAP homely homeless housing and prevention it is already administered through the COC I'm intrigued to know how point five of your recommendation first your priorities will be implemented the city of Chico plans to execute operating and performance audits and updates for all shelters receiving city state or federal funding city CD BG funding absolutely is the city suggesting they are now going to be auditing a CHAP dollars or the books of NGOs the county took over as the administrative entity and as the collaborative applicant of the COC in 2019 is the city of Chico suggesting they want that administrative position back if now you know this comes with a responsibility of managing the HMIS system as well as the coordinated entry system priority seven states enhance county relationships with mental health partners and service providers how will the city of Chico enhance the county's relationship with partners the county is specifically tasked with providing behavioral health I'm sorry and I didn't even get to how the inappropriate use of opioid settlement funds Katie Toma followed by Stephen Hazel and then Catherine T good evening my name is Katie Toma and I'm the executive director of the Chico Builders Association we want to thank the city manager and her team for the work they have done in putting the strategic plan together in short order the issues at hand are complex and it has been stated there's no silver bullet to resolve them you should have received a letter from us this afternoon where we identified two recommendations CBA recommends that the plan establish a policy objective of a thousand foot setback for unauthorized encampments and related camping activities along waterways subject to legal review and appropriate implementation through city ordinances protecting Chico's waterways should be explicit and should be an explicit priority with clear enforcement expectations secondly CBA recommends that the plan clearly establish a citywide approach doing to encampment response enforcement cleanup and restoration priority should be determined by documented public safety environment environmental and accessibility concerns rather than geographic location alone every business every neighborhood and business district deserves the same commitment to clean safe and accessible public spaces addition lastly as stated in our letter in keeping with CBA's mission to serve our community with our resources we stand ready to offer our expertise and assistance on matters related to building and development thank you for your consideration and your continued service to the city of Chico thank you thank you Steven Hazel followed by Catherine Tee and then Miami Hammond you
yeah Steven Hazel God remember I'm God hey a rank-and-file guess what it should be huh that you're one of seven of you know over 100,000 of us you represent us but then this guy come Vinny leapfrog over you huh I know it's a beehive I got an authority over you but about that strategic Jill you said you had oh I got right here that was a great town hall we got a whole one minute to speak as I spent over an hour you couldn't even give us two minutes like right here you give us two minutes why couldn't you give us three minutes there's only 14 speakers that's what I'm talking about see this is an important issue is one lady needed three minutes couldn't give us three minutes people died from my right to speak and you as an individual because you just got a personal thing I'm not your special needs child okay I'm an individual we expect to be treated fairly and equally okay now I'll give us Shout out to Overby.
Hey, he lives in my district. You guys lost, but you know what? He had it right with Mark Spells. Remember Mark Spells? Man, dude, you had it, dude. I appreciate you sticking up for him, okay? What does Pete Stewart, JFK Junior, and Mark Spells have in common? All their planes were fixed to crash, okay? Other than that, this St. Jude plan, what a joke. Man, $300,000? Whoa, I just gave them $1,000 a piece. This St. Jude plan, what? What a joke. It's like $285,000 for two security guards. That's what we got. Oh, that's a good, or a million dollars for the airport. More money to spend. You guys didn't even know what you're doing. I got the money from the Mormon church. I got $3 billion. I got $500 million for you, you guys.
And guess what? Not only that, but there's free parking downtown. So I'm gonna get parking and take care of that. You get free parking. I got the homes. I got my tiny old town guy right there in the front row. You can have all the tiny homes. That's time, thank you. You can have the old tiny old town in Chico. And that's my guy right there. That's time. My church guy. There he is, my tiny old town. So Catherine T., followed by Miami Hammond, and then Anika Rodriguez. So Catherine T., Miami Hammond. So I'd like to give a brief kind of a history of the reason why we have this mentally ill homeless problem. Now, there used to be big institutions all across America, and they housed mentally ill homeless people until they died.
And then there was World War I, where there was PTSD, and doctors found Thorazine, and they cured them. And then the mental institutions saw that they cured their people. And so all of a sudden, Reagan has opened the doors to these big institutions, and the county was supposed to pick up the mentally ill homeless situation by having the programs in place for when they were all released. Now, there was a time when there was no mentally ill homeless problem, because they were in these large institutions. So when they started curing them, there was no reason to hold them there anymore. And I think it was Reagan, when he was the governor of California, or maybe when he was president, who wanted the counties to make some kind of thing where these mentally ill people out of these large institutions were going to be helped.
So you have an unhoused program, and her idea is about safe shelter, hotel vouchers. But a lot of these people are schizophrenic, and they have all kinds of problems, and they don't want to go to these shelters. And nothing you say is gonna make them want to go there. And this is not just a problem for Chico. It's all over the place. All counties, everyone's dealing with these homeless mentally ill people that were, well, they're not really a victim. They've all been let out of these institutions because of PTSD and the Thorazine that cured the soldiers was found to cure the mentally ill until they're out on their own and don't take these drugs. So you need the police officers to go through town, schizophrenic, whatever, and give them at least a hotel voucher so they can get out of the rain, because they're not normal.
If they're not gonna want to go to that Genesis shelter. Now, this lady had some good ideas. The safe shelter, parking in your car, the hotel voucher, which I wish she would do. That's time, thank you. Myomi Hammond, followed by Anika Rodriguez, and then Ms. Jenny Lang. Hi, Mayor and City Council. I wasn't prepared because I didn't realize there was a meeting tonight. But I had written you guys a proposal for the Genesis shelter, and I wanted to speak to Amber about it prior to talking to you about it. Well, I guess I'm gonna talk to you about it anyways. There's several of us that are at the Genesis shelter now, and we wanted to know if there was the possibility of closing off or fencing off maybe 10 to 20 units and do a pilot program.
I spoke to a rehab here in Chico that would be willing to do video groups so that they don't have to come on site and have the proper permits, and they could do it from the office. And they offer incentives for people to stay clean where you can do a weekly test and you get a gift. And once you hit a six-week mark, and I know they wanna open a rehab, but that's way down the road. What about the people that are there now? Because you guys are gonna change it to what, 12 months? Everybody that's there now, if they don't get clean or get a job or go to school, we're gonna end up on the street and back at the shelter, and it's gonna be a revolving door. There's a lot of us that don't want that. We really wanna change.
I've got a whole business plan drawn up for this rehab that is willing to help and do video groups. And I think it would benefit a lot of us that are there now, and we're asking, please, please give us this opportunity. I don't know who I submit paperwork to or letters or any of that, so that we can get the help that we need. There's a lot of us that need help and wanna change. That's all I've got right now. Thank you for coming and speaking to us. We appreciate it. Thank you, Anika Rodriguez, followed by Jenny Ling, and then we have two people on Zoom. Anika. The supervisor who represents the vast majority of the city of Chico, I think Tammy Ritter should have been involved in the stakeholder discussion.
As for the use of opioid funds, the city-state's mental health and substance use treatment is a key component. While the city continues to contract with the sobering, will the city continue to contract with the sobering centers beyond 26-27? 70 to 85% of the funds are supposed to be used for opioid remediation programs designed to address misuse, treat addiction, and mitigate the opioid crisis. Remediations include overdose reversal, treatment, medication, and harm reduction. Is using the settlement dollars for police overtime in line with the settlement dollars? Thank you, Ms. Jenny Ling, and then Greg Scott. Good evening, everyone. I'm Jenny Ling, and I work with a couple of nonprofit organizations here in Chico.
My only concerns, I understand that we have to start somewhere, and I also understand we have a deadline. But I want us to move carefully as we head into a big change, because we are dealing with humans. I am certain that if this conversation was about dogs or cats or birds or iguanas, there would be so much more compassion in regards to it, because everyone says they can't take care of themselves. They need us. They didn't make this choice for themselves. But then we don't stop and think that same way for quite a few of these folks on the streets. As another person said, a lot of these people are dealing with trauma. Now, of course, if you've never had any ACEs in your life, adverse childhood experiences, then you, of course, cannot relate.
Life has been pretty rosy. A stubbed toe is a difficult day. However, a lot of these persons that you're dealing with have genuine fear, genuine fear that has been built on top of itself, because they have had repeated experiences of hoping coming into places like this, like our last speaker, and saying, I want to change, I need help, but there's no measure in the plan for what she's asked for. That's my concern. So if you're going to adopt this plan, prepare to make changes, because this cannot be the one that we stay with. Thank you. Thank you. And then Greg Scott is on Zoom. So go ahead, Greg, if you can. Can you hear us, Greg? Can you speak? Is he muted? Says he's unmuted. Can he hear us?
I would assume he wouldn't. I can't tell. You can't tell? Oh, is it not? Do you not have video? Okay. Let's put him on hold, and let's try the next one, and see if it's a... That person lowered their hand. Oh, they lowered their hand. Darn it. Okay. Sorry. Sorry, Greg, if you can hear us. We tried. All right. And that is it. That is our final speaker. All right. Questions for staff, comments from the dais, where are we going to go? All right, Council Member Hawley. Yep. I mean, obviously, it's something to note that a supervisor came and spoke, and it was my assumption that we had engaged the county to some capacity before this, so I think maybe some reassurance that we can... You know, this is a living document, as you stated before, Ms. Haen, and we'll continue to engage with the county in the future, and clarify with all representatives, I'm sure.
Yes, through the mayor, I'd love to clarify. We did engage with all the county departments that are part of, and the COC themselves as well. Erik was just at the meeting this week with them, and had conversations. I do want to clarify, I think maybe there was a misunderstanding. The city is in no way intending to take over the role of the COC. The plan itself just talks about enhancing those partnerships, and our participation at the COC, so apologies if that was misunderstood, but that's not the intention. I think it's a really important function, and I'm used to, in Sonoma County and Solano County, both working very closely with our COC to partner and garner that support together, because more can be done when there's more people at the table, especially with grant funding and all of those areas.
It is not our intention to audit anything that they oversee, or that they are currently implementing. The audit is really talking about the shelters that we control as the city, and looking at our processes and contracting and stuff. If they're receiving our CDBG funding or other funding, then we would look at it as we always have, so there's no intention to change that. Happy to clarify that in the plan if it's helpful, but yeah, we're not asking to take over HNYS. We're not asking to take over any of the role of the COC. We appreciate all the work that they do, and we hope to further partner together, and move our shared goals forward. Thank you, Ms. Haen. I hope you didn't feel put on the spot, but I thought it was important you had an opportunity to respond before the public.
Thank you. Oh, and if you wanted me to clarify on the opioid funding, I'm happy to do that as well. In Vallejo, I've used opioid funding in many different ways, and we definitely will make sure that every dollar that is spent is compliant with the settlement, and some of the areas of compliance for spending are public safety, law enforcement programming, jail infrastructure, housing vouchers, outreach, education, mitigating any effects of opioid crisis, any sort of intervention, any fix. So there are many areas. It's very broad, and we definitely will make sure that the target team outreach, for example, will be funded through opioid. Whatever it is, we'll make sure that we're compliant, and we won't be spending our opioid funding inappropriately.
Thank you. Did you want to address while you're at it the Sobering Center? I've never heard anything that we would not continue to support that. That's a very specific item, and in my understanding, we are still supporting that. No, I think it's a great partnership, and I think we want to move forward and continue that as much as possible. Okay. I don't have anybody else in the queue, so I'll ask my question. Mr. City Attorney, can you address the comment that we don't want to end up right back where we are? Is there anything in this plan that would lead us back to that? And then I was going to ask about the opioid use, but that's already- Yeah, no, we very carefully reviewed it. We don't believe that there's any legal issues there.
Obviously, people can sue for any variety of things, but we think it's very defensible and legally supported. All right, thank you. Council Member O'Brien. Yeah, thank you, Mayor. Obviously, this has been an issue that we all, and every community has struggled with for the most part, and every document is going to be imperfect. We could sit here and pick apart this document if we so chose to do so, but it really doesn't move the ball down the field, and the approach this takes, compassion and accountability, some wise person several years ago used that phrase, and I'm glad to see we're choosing that concept again, because that is the balanced approach you need with this issue, and every community really needs to adopt.
There's a lot of good points that people brought up that I agree with, and Supervisor Ritter will make sure that we work with the county in a collaborative way, just like Ms. Haen mentioned. Ms. Lang, I think you're right. This is just a start. This is just a start, but we have to do something. We can sit on our hands, we can continue to debate this issue, or we can step out realizing the plan will not be perfect and make some progress. It will not be solved in a year, but we can make some progress in a year, but I will guarantee you if we don't do anything tonight, we will not do anything in the next year. So I think we need to move the ball forward, like I said, adopt this plan, understanding that it is a living and breathing document, that we can make adjustments as we move along.
I get that. That's how government works, but doing nothing is not going to solve anything for this community. I'm sorry. Okay, Sergeant Burns can... You're interrupting, sir, you're interrupting a public meeting. Council Member Goldstein. Well, once again, very grateful for our city manager's initiative on this plan. I feel like we're going to be a bit distracted if I keep speaking. Hopefully all can be peaceful and folks can sit and enjoy our meeting. Just giving it one second. So thank you again to our city manager and our staff who worked on this plan. I believe it's essential that we plan for addressing homelessness post-war and I'm glad that it seems like our council and community generally can agree on that.
I like that this plan includes strategies that pair shelter and support systems with strategic enforcement to protect our parks, paths and sidewalks and protect people. I think it's important to center the people who are experiencing homelessness and I'm glad that they have been engaged in this plan as well as our service provider community. And it looks like we've made some movements towards making sure that this plan better reflects what our service provider community actually needs. And I'm sure that we can continue in the future as we learn new strategies or new needs in our community that we can amend our plan as needed. So I think this is a good start and we can build on it. So yeah, I also want to highlight some of my key parts of this plan that I like, like the safe car parking program, extreme weather centers and gathering data.
And I'm grateful that we've already been able to address the questions that I was going to ask that our community members brought up. So thank you to everybody who's taken part in planning this and also speaking up. Council Member Hawley. I'd like to make a motion to adopt the resolution and improve the unhoused strategic plan for implementation as well as approve use of opioid settlement funding totaling $300,000 for plan and implementation in a separate. Second. Vice Mayor Bennett. So I would like to take this opportunity to thank City Manager Haen as well as Assistant City Manager Gustafson and our City Attorney for all of the work that you put together to develop this plan. It's a first step for us in the right direction.
We will be moving forward with this plan and I'm sure our city, our community will be better off with this in place and moving forward. So I just want to say thank you. Council Member Winslow. Thank you. Thank you, City Manager Haen and Erik Gustafson for putting this together and presenting so well and I think incorporating so many views from the public. It was not inevitable that we would have so much consensus and support for something like this and I think it is a testament to how well you've come in as a mediator to be able to pull this together. At this time, I want to emphasize two things that I think are really important coming out of this and one is that we move towards a recognition by the city that enforcement should not happen when people don't have another option, that people have basic human needs and that we don't ticket people or arrest them unless they're able to meet their basic needs in some kind of reasonable way.
And it's not in every way explicit in this, it's not. explicit in our laws, but I think that's okay. Laws can change as lawmakers change. And I will say that I don't see it as about compassion so much. Human rights are for everybody. I think it's more about having a government that's accountable, that they aren't able to infringe on people's basic needs without some kind of reasonable alternative for them. And this is really good for everybody in the long run because we never know where we're gonna be in the future. The other side of it is I'm really excited and I think that most of the community should be to see that we're gonna see some restoration of our parks and open spaces and public spaces are gonna be treated differently from now on.
And there's one request I wanna make for a slight alteration, just a slight addition that if you'll allow, I would seek some consensus in this. And it is in the plan action A10, it says map priority sites and restoration status and specifying the deliverable, it says include seven 30 and 90 day checks and include wildfire risk areas. And all I would like to do is emphasize the priority that I hear from the community very broadly and include waterways and bike paths in addition to wildfire risk areas there so that we're able to track it as best we can, progress in ensuring what I think is a quite reasonable goal is that we do not have camping and waterways anymore. That's just a request for a friendly amendment.
So request for a friendly amendment to add to A10 waterways and bike paths? Yeah. I don't know that bikeways would fall into restoration status. I think just the idea that they're not inhibited by camping. Whatever, yeah. I would add one small friendly amendment. I don't think this one will be an issue, if we could actually make it part of the motion that says to return to the council to provide a six month progress update. Could we make that every six months for the two year plan? Dot just one update. That's on page 18 of Council Member Holly, if you're looking for it. It's just under the tracking shared progress and that says to return to council for six months, for a six month, I'm just asking for every six months.
Yeah, I just want to make sure for the entirety of the six month progress update, is that already in the draft plan somewhere? It's not just in the presentation. It doesn't need to be in there. We can add it on the motion that we would get a report back every six months. I think that's appropriate. Thank you. All right, we have a motion and a second. I have nobody else in the queue. Who's up? Okay, so we're going to take the, we're going to do the approval of the plan by the adoption of the resolution first. And that was with two friendly amendments on A10, include waterways and bike paths to the fire hazard areas. And then another friendly amendment for a six month progress update to the council throughout the two year period.
Okay, so let me, Council Member Goldstein. Yes. Council Member Holly. Yes. Council Member O'Brien. Yes. Council Member van Overbeek. Yes. Council Member Winslow. Yes. Vice Mayor Bennett. Yes. Mayor Reynolds. Aye. Carried seven, zero. And then, okay, go ahead. Do you want another motion? For the approval of the 300,000 and the supplemental. A motion to approve 4.4. I'll make a motion to approve the supplemental. Second. Just a second. All right. Okay. Council Member Goldstein. Yes. Council Member Holly. Yes. Council Member O'Brien. Yes. Council Member van Overbeek. Yes. Council Member Winslow. Yes. Vice Mayor Bennett. Yes. Mayor Reynolds. Aye. Carried seven, zero. All right. Before we go to our public hearings for sewer rate, we are going to take a break.
10 minutes and we will be back.
Thank you.
Mayor. All right. Item 5.1, sewer rate adjustment. We have Mr. Brendan Ottoboni, our Department of Public Works Engineering. Yes. And Deputy Director David Kehn will be doing the presentation on this item. Good evening, members of Council, Vice Mayor Bennett, Mayor Reynolds. My name is David Kehn, Deputy Director of Public Works Engineering. And tonight we will be discussing the sewer rate adjustment and continuing the public hearing. So this is what we'll talk about tonight. First, we'll go over the background, and then we'll discuss the current rate methodology, the revised proposed rate methodology, and the financing strategies to impact, to mitigate some of the impacts from that. And then we'll talk about the revised sewer bill impact, talk about the actual numbers that we'll see, and then we'll close with public outreach and staff's recommendation.
So this was originally brought to Council's attention in November 2025, when the Director of Finance identified sewer fund reserve issues. This was largely driven by deferred maintenance and upcoming regulatory requirements. Then in February and March of 2026, staff presented to the Finance Committee on those challenges facing the sewer fund. And then in March 2026, staff brought forth a $134.5 million CIP and a cash versus debt option with a large increase in year one, followed by minor increases in years two through five. That was originally approved by Council, but then rescinded where Council asked us to look at other CIP options. In June 2026, staff presented several CIP options and Council went with a moderate risk, $106 million CIP, a cash funded approach.
And instead of that large year one increase, spreading that impact over the first two years, followed by three years of minor increases. At that meeting, Council directed staff to initiate the Prop 218 notice. Those mailers were sent out. However, staff continue to hear Council's input and we continue to hear what the public was saying, in particular commercial restaurants. So we continue to look at the rates and we continue to look at the assumptions built into those rates, including the billing methodology. We called other cities like Redding, Sacramento, Fairfield, Manteca, Livermore, all these other utilities. And one of the primary things we found is there is no industry standard for sewer billing.
It's done in a variety of ways and the way that the City of Chico does it is unique. So we continue to look at those opportunities. And then in September, we came to Council at the public hearing and we asked for Council to direct us to look at these alternative billing methodologies, to optimize and look for opportunities to mitigate some impacts to our commercial businesses and see if there's a better way to spread the cost of service analysis amongst customers. So here we are tonight and we are gonna ask Council to close the public hearing and then look at these revised rate methodologies. And then ultimately, we're going to ask Council to ask staff to initiate a new Prop 218 notice. So I talked about it, but I wanted to be clear.
One of the primary assumptions in this sewer rate study was that we utilize the same billing methodology that was adopted in the 2022 sewer rate study. This was defensible, it was performed by an external consultant, and so it seemed like a reasonable assumption. But as I mentioned, other utilities do it different and there is a wide range of how these sewer billing methodologies can be applied. Sacramento Sewer utilizes a, or commercial businesses for restaurants that use a square footage for this size. The utilities have a high, medium, and low strength. City of Chico uses customer classes. So there is a wide range in how these things are applied. So our current billing methodology for residential uses a fixed monthly cost that does not change with a volumetric rate.
However, our commercial customers have a slightly more complicated formula. The fixed monthly charge takes into account what's called an equivalent dwelling unit. And what an equivalent dwelling unit is, is it compares the volume and strength of a commercial business compared to an average residential business. And then on top of that, we put the volumetric rates. Something to notice is that volume is accounted for in both the fixed monthly charge and the volumetric rate. So after looking at these other utilities, what we're proposing tonight is a new billing methodology that has a fixed monthly charge for residential that does not change, and a fixed monthly charge for commercial that does not change.
On top of that is a volumetric rate. Now we are still taking into account cost of service principles by allocating those costs based on the strength of user. So for example, a restaurant would pay roughly 3.2 times more per gallon than a residential customer. They have a higher strength, they should pay more per gallon. So this revised billing methodology, it's simpler. It's easier for customers to calculate their bill and it's easier for City of Chico customer service representatives to explain the bill. Removing that fixed monthly charge with that volumetric component does shift some of the revenue requirements from commercial to residential. This can be interpreted as putting the burden of commercial businesses onto residential, but it's important to realize that cost of service analysis are based on layers and layers of assumptions.
The first assumption is we don't know how much these people are discharging. We know how much water they're using in December through March, and we make the assumption that that's what they're using all year. The second assumption is that all customer classes have the same strength. What about a Chinese restaurant versus a sandwich shop? They're both restaurants, do they have the same strength? So there are layers of assumptions, and what we found is that different utilities, they can do it in different ways depending on the consultant and depending on the community needs. And this proposed method is actually more in line with other utilities that we've seen. So what has changed and what has remained the same?
We're still proposing this $106 million moderate risk CIP, same O&M costs, same assumptions for inflation. What's been revised is the billing methodology, and then we have some debt proposals that will mitigate some of the impacts from that shift in revenue requirements. So before I talk about the revenue increases, I wanna be absolutely clear that this is the overall revenue increase needed for the Sewer Enterprise Fund. Customer bill impacts will change depending on customer class and how much they use, but this is how much money the city needs to increase their revenue in order to accomplish the CIP, operations and maintenance, and debt service that we have to pay for. So what was notified in the Prop 218 notice was a 55% year one, 55% year two, and then 3% throughout the five-year rate study.
What we're recommending tonight is a 55% year one, and that would be in April, 2027. However, given the timing of rate increases typically happening in July, we recognize that July is three months right after April, and so we are still able to accomplish our revenue requirements with that 55% pushed out to July, 2028, and then 3% moving forward. If council wants to mitigate some of those impacts in the short term, debt financing is an option. As you can see, it's roughly 10 to 15% per year, and if you look over to the right under the cumulative impact, there is a significant savings over the five-year term. However, this money is not free. We have to pay it back with interest. So a $40 million loan would end up costing the city about $60 million over the life of the loan.
So there is benefit, but it's short term, and you have to pay for it in the long term. It's a tool that can be used and something for council to consider as we look at the sewer bill impacts on upcoming slides. So I'm gonna spend some time here. This is an example sewer bill impact for residentials, and we're gonna look at a high-usage restaurant. So an average residential uses about 54, or they discharge about 5,400 gallons, I'm sorry, 5,400 gallons of sewage to the system monthly. A high-usage restaurant discharges about 53,000 gallons of sewage to the system monthly. So those are what we're gonna look at over the coming years. So under the currently noticed Prop 218, average residential would go from 37 to 54.
What we're recommending is from 37 to 59, but here's where you see the savings on the commercial side. A high-restaurant user would go from 853 to 1233. Under the current proposal, they would go from 853 to 924. Then we have this middle year, and as I talked about, due to the timing, that second rate increase would be pushed out to July 2028. So we'll jump out there so we really have an apples-to-apples comparison after both those large rate increases take effect. And so as you can see, a house would end up at $86 under the currently notified Prop 218 notice. What we're recommending today is that they would go up to $92. So as you can see, that's a $6 increase. And then if we look at restaurants, under the currently noticed high-usage restaurants, under the currently noticed Prop 218, they would jump to 969.
But as we're recommending tonight, it would drop them down to 1432, which is a savings of over $500. And the reason for that is we are almost 90% residential. So this impact is spread over a large residential base, and the customers that are commercial, it's relatively small, so there's a big impact there. And as I talked about, it's not shifting the burden, it's a different way of looking at the same challenge. If council, we recognize that it was notified at 86 for a house, and now it's going up to 92. So if council wants to mitigate those impacts in the short run, you can look at debt financing and have them go, as noticed at 86, down to 80. And then if a 60 million debt option, it goes from 86 down to 78.
One thing to realize here is you don't get much more benefit from jumping from 40 to $60 million debt. So if council wants to go with debt, we recommend the $40 million option, because that's where you see your primary savings. But it's also important to realize the cash-funded approach is 92, and you save 12 bucks a month for an average residential house. For a $40 million debt, that's committed over 20 years. So there is quite a commitment there. Same story with the restaurants. You see the primary savings in the change in billing methodology. If council wants to mitigate short-term effects, they can go with debt, take it from 1432 down to 1251, and then even further down to 1208 when you increase that debt.
So depending on what council wants to do tonight, what we're requesting is that you direct us to initiate a new Prop 218 notice. That would go out to all the customers with the new rates. We would update the online sewer bill calculator. We maintain resources for the public to learn about the sewer system. We continue to be engaged with local media. And then, of course, we have a public process timeline available on the website. It has all meeting materials, agendas, videos, presentations available since this began in November 2025. Oops. Standby. There we go. So tonight, staff is recommending that council continue and then close the public hearing, select a financing strategy, either cash or debt, and then direct staff to initiate a new Proposition 218 notice based on the revised billing methodology.
If council takes that action tonight, we will be back again in February, where we will have another public hearing, and we will ask council to adopt the rates at that time. If council adopts the rates, the new rates would go into effect in April 2027. With that second big rate increase coming in July 2028, followed by minor increases throughout the five-year study. So that concludes my presentation, and I'm happy to answer any questions. Council Member Ranno, rec. Thank you, David. That was a great presentation. So on the $40 million, on the financing option, the financing, the numbers you put up there for proposed rates, those are examples. But if we get $40 or $60 million in debt, and I agree with you, I think 40 is the right number, we have flexibility in the ramp, the increase, the slope of the ramp is we have to increase the rates, right?
These aren't, I wanna make it clear that the 45% is not, it could be 35%, right? It means you pay more later, but there's flexibility when you have financing, it gives you the ability to change the slope of the ramp or the rate increase. This debt financing model assumes that we won't get the debt for a couple years. We would target low-interest loans through the state, so the sewer revenue model does assume that the debt will come in a couple years. I think that's what you're getting at. However, this is the overall revenue increase, and I wanna be clear that individual customer bill impacts will vary depending on their customer class and usage. So I've done a little bit of investigation and muni bonds are secured by a dedicated revenue stream like sewer bonds are fairly easy to get.
So I think we could make it happen quicker than that. I mean, I would defer to Ms. Martin, but. Yeah, and we've been in contact with iBank, which is a state agency, and they could give us the debt financing within six months. We would pay higher than 4%, but that is certainly an option. If we go the long route and target those low-interest state loans, we can get near 3%, maybe even lower, but those also come with strings. Can't pay a PAC sooner, and there's other strings attached to those low-interest loans. So certainly we are in contact with iBank, which is a state agency, and we would go that path if that's what directed by Council. Any other questions for staff before we go to speakers?
Vice Mayor Bennett. No. Ms. Martin, we could take out a loan or go into debt financing at any time, couldn't we? If we pass it as recommended, could we, and something didn't go right, something went wrong, we could look at financing at any time we wanted to, as long as it didn't increase or setting a ceiling so anything below that is permissible. Is that correct? Yeah. Thank you for pointing that out. I think that it's important to note that these are the ceilings that you're approving by these rates, and if at any time we want to change course and do debt financing or capital projects change and the costs are lower, we can always implement lower rates based on those circumstances that are at that time.
You'll probably be happy that we get this result and won't have to bother you anymore. Thank you. All right. I don't see any other speakers, so how many speakers do we have? We have seven. All right. Three minutes each. All right. Molly Kopta. That was three minutes each? Yeah. Okay. Followed by Kim Dietz and then Brandon Slater. Good evening once again, City Council. I don't mean to do that every time, my apologies. I'm here to speak on behalf of the Chamber of Commerce as well as the business community as a whole. The plan that we have been provided, we do not feel as though we can endorse it at this time. We have a couple of requests for additional information, but also feedback that we'd like to know has been received and reviewed.
The current information that's been provided to us has not demonstrated that the increases that are proposed are the lowest necessary to fund critical infrastructure. We would like to see an external validation of these financial assumptions and independently verified financial assumptions of collections, revenue recovery, and cost allocation. We would like to have a full evaluation of financing options and the visibility into those, bond funding, debt financing, any other mechanisms that we have to ensure that we are not passing on this cost to our ratepayers without due diligence. The City clearly, we would also like to see the City clearly demonstrate all financing alternatives have been explored and exhausted.
Before increasing rates, we would like to reiterate this once again. Please exhaust every possible option before you pass along this request for funding to the community. The concerns around how this will impact the bottom line for businesses is sizable and will have a heavy impact. And it's not without noting that if businesses close, you will also not be able to collect the funding that is necessary for these projects. So as we look at this, we do need to look at that as a potential impact of how high we raise those rates and how we must structure that to ensure that we have the least amount of impact while still ensuring we have critical infrastructure funding. Thank you for your time. Thank you.
Kim Dietz, followed by Brandon Slater, and then Kenneth Richards. Well, you guys, this seems like it's been an ongoing issue for a long time. I'm Kim Dietz, resident of Chico since 1982. My husband and I own 22 residential rental units and manage an additional three units for family and friends. Why not? I've provided public comment on this before, a few times on this issue. My bottom line, and I'd hate to speak on behalf of the entire rental property managers and owners, but bottom line, any increase in sewer is going to be directly passed on to our renters. So be wise, be kind, and do whatever you need to do and try to manage it the best way you can because it's going to be a direct result.
We really won't have any options. So I urge you to consider a debt-financed approach to help the overall rent increases keep these down. And passing along stuff to residents on behalf of the businesses doesn't seem right either. So again, 22 rental units and an additional three that I manage, and please do your best job and just get this over with. At some point, we're going to have to just bite the bullet and do it, but try to make it as fair as possible for everybody. Thank you. Brandon Slater, Kenneth Richards, and then Katie Thoma. Back. Good job earlier. So unfortunately, I didn't get a chance to like go through the whole thing until like Friday and got you guys some comments or questions, likely Friday.
So staff hasn't had a chance to get back to me, but I think I just want to like, I would, my hope is that you guys don't vote tonight and that you give us a little bit more time to kind of work through some issues. But my, I have a strong opinion that there are some math errors. The, just the amount of the loan payment saying that it's a 4% loan and that the $3.2 million is the loan payment per year. That's just wrong. I mean, maybe there's a whole bunch of fees included in there, but it's off by like $300,000 a year. So from my perspective, you should either say it's a 5. Or a 4.96% rate or say something about what the fees are, how we're getting there. So in my opinion, that's wrong. I also just of note, if you do choose the cash financing option and you go with a 550-5533 over the period of time, you actually only generate $86 million, not the 106 that you think you're going to get.
So from my perspective, I think that's just wrong. So you guys should look into that. If you're going to get the only the $86 million, and then you turn around and you, and I think that it's also wrong in that the $40 million, I agree that $40 million is the right number to go for, for debt, for probably different reasons than what was described before. Once you get the $60 and higher million, it starts over a 20-year period, it starts tailing off on, instead of having increasing revenues available for Capital Improvement Project, it starts tailing off if you look at it on a long-term basis. Let's see, what other things? Oh, I think the assumptions around, I think at some point we didn't really have a methodology for a tool for enforcing, so there's some people that just haven't been paying.
So the assumptions for non-payment I think are higher once we get this process where we can put a lien on properties that people don't pay, I'm looking at my notes here. Anyways, I hope you guys just take a bit of a, just give us another two weeks. If you are going to do it, do the $40 million in debt, but I think that the 55% should be, the delta between should really be bigger, like the impact to the rate should be more than what they're currently calculating. So I want to see the backup for that. Thanks. Thank you. Kenneth Richards, Katie Toma, and then Stephen Hazel. Hello, thank you for having me here. My name is Kenneth Richards and I was here on September 15th and I had addressed you that I was a working man, I worked 40 hours a week for 44 years of my life before I retired in June of 2023.
So I'm now on a fixed income of Social Security. And so when I get a notice like this, it says the current rate is $32 a month and it's going to go to $49.60. By my math, that's a 35% increase. Now there's different ways to crunch the numbers, but that's what my math comes up with. So when I was working for 44 years of my life for three different companies, do you know how many times my bosses gave me a 35% pay increase? So what I could have done is I could have gone to my bosses and said, hey, look, you know what? My house is getting old, my cars are rusting away, the tires are going bald, my infrastructure is going bad. You know what I think somebody might have said to me? They would have said, Mr. Richards, you've been earning income for many, many years.
You knew that your house was going to get old. You knew that your cars were going to age. You should have been saving money all along because this is something that's part of a natural process. You should have been allocating money for future expenditures. That's the responsible thing to do. Since we love you as a good, hard worker, we'll be willing to give you a 5% merit increase, which is what I would be for. If this thing had given me a number that said a 5% increase or even a 7% or 8%, I understand costs go up, I wouldn't be down here bothering you. What I would ask to anybody in these rooms, and you can encourage your friends and family, go to write a letter to Social Security and tell them that you need a 35% cost pay increase.
See what they say. Or for those of you who are living on an IRA, tell your finance guy, hey, I need a 35% return on my investment next year. See what he says. For those of you who are still working for a living, as I did, go to your boss and ask him for a 35% pay increase, and then come back, we should come back to the next meeting and report to the council what all those people said. So I don't have an extra $17 a month to grab out of thin air. I don't know where you folks think I'm supposed to get it from. I got to tighten the belt, so why can't you? Thank you. Katie Toma, followed by Steven Hazel, and then Greg Scott. We'll try it again on the Zoom. Perfect. Thank you. Good evening, once again.
So the Chico Builders Association received a copy of the sewer rate study staff report from, I received it from the CBA board member, Brandon Slater, on November 10th, the same day he received it from city staff. CBA had previously been assured that the staff report would be provided on November 2nd or 3rd, allowing sufficient time for our third-party expert consultant to review the proposed changes and provide an independent analysis. Unfortunately, the delay significantly reduced the time available for a thorough review. We received our consultant's report just today, and have not yet to have the opportunity to evaluate its findings in their entirety. However, our preliminary review raises serious concerns regarding the legality of certain proposed actions, as well as the apparent redistribution of the proposed rate increases from commercial to residential ratepayers, rather than a meaningful reduction in the overall financial burden.
These concerns warrant further discussion and careful consideration before the City moves forward. CBA respectfully requests that Council defer action on the following staff recommendations already listed to you. CBA would appreciate the opportunity to meet with City staff, along with our independent consultant, to review the analysis, discuss the concerns identified, and better understand the methodology underlying the proposed rate adjustments. Given the magnitude of the proposed increases and their long-term financial implications for Chico residents and businesses, we believe it is reasonable and responsible to allow sufficient time for an informed review before Council makes a decision that will establish the foundation for a new Prop 218 process.
Our request is not intended to unnecessarily delay the process, but rather to ensure that the proposed rates are legally defensible, equitable, transparent, and based on sound financial assumptions. Thank you for your consideration. Thank you. And Hazel, and then Greg Scott. Give me a little latitude here. And remember, this has been going on for a while. Remember Katie Hawley, ever so concerned, Katie Hawley had the motion and you guys got all upset because she said, hey, man, that's it. And that was it. And boy, you guys did everything on your side, man. The next thing, well, you should have had reconsideration of action at preceding meeting, and you wouldn't have used public presentation, wouldn't have used Dale Bennett to use his Council request to put it, to agendize it for the 10th, 20th time.
Okay. This thing has been kicked down the road like crazy. Now, of course, the concern, Katie Hawley said, is there any programs? I know something was mentioned about the CARE program in PG&E, which I have CARE, so I could put, say some drugs or like, you know, a poor person under CARE, what's so bad about that? CARE is a good, you know, thing. And to apply it to the sewer, which is good, if you can figure a program, that'd be great. Now, not only the CARE program, but I want to add something to that. The IHEAP program, it's the In-Home Energy Assistance Program run by the Community Action Agency of Butte County, which actually, I don't pay anything for PG&E. I got a credit this year, actually, for $569, just my last year credit, $540.
I had $453 for the credit last year. My bill, this, you know, this is a PG&E bill, it could be a sewer bill. It's only $30. That's a dollar a day. And I got a credit of $230 left. I don't pay PG&E. My dream has come true. I came from Santa Clara. We had our own power plant. I thought we had the cheapest electricity ever, but it turned out, no. I just realized, wait, I could apply this to this. You know what I'm going to do? I don't, I want all of you to have free electricity. I want you to have free parking. You know what? I'm going to give you the money so you could build this sewer in gold. And Donald Trump is going to trip on that. Oh yeah, all the pipes could be solid 24 karat gold. Okay, it could be, but it's not because I'm not going to waste it.
You know what? You know where you're going to get the money? Because the reason why you don't have the money, you don't accept God. I'm here. I'm like 35 years after this guy born in 1924 because you don't want him to be president. That's who I am. I'm born in 12-6. The other guy is 6-12. Whenever he sees 6-12, that's his birthday. That's the time Trump got up from the ashes, 6-12. He rose to 6-12. That's Darlene. Okay. Okay. Darlene Graham's birthday is 6-12. It is. He's bad. Okay. I'll leave it at that. Whenever he sees 6-12, it's Satan. That's him. Okay. It's O.J. Happened on 6-12. Post-Nightclub 6-12. I'll keep going on and on. Okay. I'm talking about this. Now, you have over $300 billion, second coming Jesus Christ.
That's where the money is. The mortgages for the second coming Jesus. Jesus is dead. 7-22-1941, 33 days before his 12th birthday, killed by a German soldier in the south of France. So, there it is. He's dead. So, oh, does that change stuff? That's time. In my book, it does. Right. Oh, God. Let's get Greg. We'll send out the- Okay. So, we will try Greg Scott on Zoom. Okay. Let's try this again. Woo-hoo. We got you this time, Greg. Old guys and new technology. I love it. And thanks for passing the homeless plan that I didn't get to say. That's a great job. First, I'd like to commend the staff for a really decent report. You know, Brendan and David and team did a pretty good job. I kind of agree with Brendan Slater.
Unless there are a lot of fees or associated other charges, there is some math errors on the $40 million loan at 4%. And I'm hoping that we, or you, approve the $40 million debt option, encourage staff to seek out funding from, for example, the Clean Water State Revolving Fund, which I know they are aware of because I'm sure they do it with the septic to sewer projects that they're doing. Because regulatory compliance issues often gain a lower interest rate, somewhere under 2% to 3%. I-Bank and conventional revenue bonds are generally going to be above market rates and probably higher than the 4%. But I think we're on the right track. I think a little bit more detailed math and detailed project development is probably required.
But I'm hoping that if you do vote on it, you vote on the $40 million debt option. Thank you very much. And y'all enjoy your evening. Thank you. He was our last speaker. All right. Glad to hear our technology was actually working and glad we got him back that time. All right. Council Member Goldstein. Well, my first question is if staff would like to take any opportunity to address any of the points brought up by our public commenters. I'm curious if there's a clarification on the questions on the math. Certainly, we did receive Mr. Slater's email on a Friday afternoon and took a look at that. So one of the key components of the debt is that we are looking to actually borrow 40 million, and so we included a half percent issuance cost as well as reaching our reserve target, so that's an additional 7.4 percent.
So the error in math, if you back that out, is that he was using 40 million as the loan when we actually want 40 million taken home. So we actually have to borrow more than 40 million in order to actually use that for projects. The other comment that I wanted to address is the revenue targets. So our sewer fund model utilizes a monthly revenue target, and the model that Mr. Slater uses an annual target, and so we noticed there was a discrepancy in that second annual increase. His went into effect in July 2029, and ours would go into effect in July 2028, with the first one occurring in April 2027, so it would only be a three month for this first year. So we did notice some errors in the spreadsheet sent to us that didn't align with our sewer fund model. Another comment that I wanted to point out on is this external validation comment. So we utilize Corollo Engineers, which is a national company. We utilize their financial management group, and they've completed over 300 rate and cost of service studies with 100 clients throughout the nation. Our project manager has over 28 years of extensive experience performing these studies, so we believe that this is third-party validated already. And then addressing the debt and the meaningful reduction, council looked at various CIP alternatives going from $134 million down to $106 million as a moderate risk, and then we also looked at around, I can't remember the exact number, but an $85 million significant risk. So we are already deferring projects from the known original CIP. Those projects don't go away. They have to be completed in years 6 through 10. So if we go with the debt option, that creates a debt floor. So once we get to years 6 through 10, we could potentially take out more debt, but that would be our limitation as we achieve those goals. So back to my original presentation, we need to increase rates and get them to a sustainable point moving forward, to the gentleman's point, so that it is on the order of three to five to seven percent annually moving forward. I think that addresses them all. Thank you.
Thank you so much for that. You were really prepared. And thank you to Brandon Slater for sending his comments early enough that staff could help address them. I appreciate that. Council Member Van Overbeek? Well, there's a couple things we know. We know that we have a mandate from the state that's about $50 million of this, and we also know that we have some quite aged out infrastructure that needs to be replaced, and that's about another half of it. Keep nodding, Brandon, but do the other thing if I go off track here. So we have to do this. We also have a timeline that's been established by the state, so that if we don't approve, and we still have some time, but what happens if we don't increase the rates enough to get the work done is the state of California takes over the management of the sewer system and takes it out of our hands, and they will increase the rates. So we have to do something. This has been discussed.
We've sent staff back to come back with new proposals three or four times, and thank you guys for being so flexible. When Brandon Slater comes up and says he's got a problem with the numbers, that stops me because, and anybody that's seen it, Mr. Slater developed a spreadsheet that gives you the ability to plug in different rates, different amounts of debt. That's really a good piece, but I don't think if there may be errors in the math, and there may not be. I think Mr. Kehn's responses were persuasive, but we can still approve this tonight, look at whatever, look and see if there are any math errors and make adjustments as we need to, but it doesn't sound like there's any huge errors in the math, if there are errors at all, but I think we need to get on with this. We've spent 15 months, 18 months talking about it, and I think we were given a five-year horizon by the state, so we're a third of the way into that. We need to do something.
Mr. Hazel, Mr. Hazel, if you're going to have signs, I need to have you go to the back of the room, please. All right, Council Member Hawley. Thank you, Mayor Reynolds. I'm in favor of using a cash-funded option for many of the reasons I've stated both in Finance Committee and in Council sessions previously, but the main reason being is that I'm not comfortable applying a $20 million price tag to something that we have a solution for now due to speculative adverse consequences as a result of the rate increases, and as Vice Mayor Bennett pointed out, which I think is very important to keep in mind, a crisis or significant business and resident concern after the sewer fee has been implemented, and they're saying we're seeing significant impacts to our livelihood and our ability to continue living in Chico because it affects our cost of living so much, we can always go back to a debt financing option.
That door will always be open, and I'm happy to explore it in the future. A couple of speakers implied that this is an attempt to pass off costs to ratepayers, and I do want to clarify again because not everyone was here for every single time this came to Council, that that unfortunately is the literal mechanism by which enterprise funds work. The service has to be financed through ratepayer charges, so that's how we fund the infrastructure. I'm not sure why some industry lobby groups and organizations have implied that they expect privileges beyond that of any other community member. I think everyone deserves to have the same equitable access to staff reports and plans that are curated, and I just want to say I look forward to maintaining that attitude for the duration of my two years on Council, but my interest is the ratepayers and residents hoping to live and work in our city for decades, and even looking at the 40 and $60 million increases, we didn't get to see the duration of increases over the 20-year lifespan. We were only looking at the next five years, and I'm comfortable being blamed and pointed at as one of the people who initiated this rate increase with a cash-funded option because I want to live in Chico 20 years from now, and I don't want to see that rate continuously increase substantially to pay off that loan. So I'd make a motion to pursue the moderate risk CIP with the revised billing methodology using a cash-funded approach, but happy to continue discussion or add amendments. I'll second the motion. Council Member Wenzel.
Thanks. I think we've landed in a really good place here. Thanks to all the people that have been part of that process, including public commentators and staff, and we have discussed this a lot. The Prop 218 notice doesn't tie a city's act rate to sets of ceiling. It makes sure that we can move forward, and I think that it's a good time for us to do that. In between debt financing and cash funded, I remain in the same place that I don't see that the marginal benefit of debt financing is worth the long-term 20-plus million dollar price tag, and I don't want to charge that on the customers of the future. I will just repeat something I said another time we had this discussion, which is that, as Mr. Scott mentioned, there are subsidized loan options, which then get us closer to the cost of inflation, and I think those make more sense, but I'm not comfortable with going with the direction that could end us up with market rate interest loans, which are going to have just like a steeper price tag in the long run. I don't think it's the best thing for our community.
Council Member O'Brien. Thank you, Mayor. So I did not initially like the cash option just from the fact it felt really onerous, and it was really onerous in particular to our businesses. I've since looked at the numbers currently with the new rate structure, and I don't see the bang for the buck with the debt options. I really don't. The numbers are not that much different, and we will be spending 20 million. By the way, that 20 million comes out of everyone's pocket regardless, and so we have to be good stewards with all our money. I want to be careful that we're not imposing a, again, a draconian fee on our businesses and our homeowners. I think this is more palatable for me to take the cash option.
Yes, it's going to hurt. No one likes that. No one likes fees. It's like pulling teeth. However, this is an urgent matter now. We have heard that. We have infrastructure needs at our sewer plant that have got to be fixed or to be fixed for us, and we will not like that option. So I'm going to support the cash option just because I think it is much more palatable now. It's not great. It's not perfect again. It never is perfect, but I can't see spending 20 or $30 million for the minimal bang for the buck that we'd be getting. Vice Mayor Bennett. I will be brief. The reason we're here is because prior councils did not make a decision. I made a decision in 2023. Yeah, was it 22? It became effective in 23. Thank you, and it didn't go far enough. We spent a great deal of time looking at rate increases and we worried about it quite a bit and made a decision, but it wasn't a good enough decision.
It was a partial. So the reason we're here and it's always painful to play catch-up, and that's the position we're in right now. We're trying to play catch-up because a decision was not made in the past. Otherwise, we wouldn't even be talking. We'd be looking at a three percent increase probably, and we'd be okay. So I just wanted to make that point because it's a big part of this whole issue is decisions were not made in the past and they should have been. So this is where we are now. Council Member Goldstein. Thank you, Mayor. I agree, Council Member Bennett. We're here because prior councils didn't make the decision, but thankfully our staff has been able to work to make this easier for our community, especially our business community, and I hope that our community can understand we aren't just choosing out of nowhere to raise sewer rates. I think we've been discussing this for months and it's hopefully very clear that we're being cautious about this, and it is time to make a decision. We have to fund our infrastructure, and I'm glad that it seems like we're able to come closer towards consensus on this and that we can, of course, I'm grateful Council Member Bennett, Vice Mayor Bennett, asked staff earlier about whether we could look into potential alternatives later if we find that we need to fund more projects sooner, things like that. Staff has done their due diligence. Really appreciate how prepared they were for our questions today. Anyway, I'm excited that we can hopefully get this done with, and I am sorry to our community members who are going to see these increased rates, but we have to increase them to some degree, and I don't see that marginal benefit of the debt financing being much better than cash. Thanks. All right, well I'm just going to chime in and defend that a future or a previous Council did make a decision. They didn't pass on this, and the same staff members that told us what that decision should be back then and it was going to be enough money ended up not being enough money, and I still have the same staff members here right now telling me that now this time it's going to be the right amount of money, and my question is, you know, how long does a restaurant have to not be able to afford to pay their water bill before their council is going to reduce their rates? If anybody ever thinks council is going to come back and reduce your rates, you're crazy. So I'm not for kicking the can down the road, but I still don't think we have the right answer and the right methodology, but sounds like you've got enough to move forward, and best of wishes. With that, we have a motion and a second. And I just want to double check, and that is your direction would be to direct staff to initiate the Prop 218 process and begin that again, along with the cash option. Okay. Yes. Okay, thank you. Council Member Goldstein? Yes. Council Member Hawley? Yes. Council Member O'Brien? Reluctantly, yes. Council Member van Overbeek? Yes. Council Member Winslow? Yes. Vice Mayor Bennett? Yes. Mayor Reynolds? Nope.
It carries 6-1. All right. You know what? We got our speakers. That's closing the public hearing, by the way. Sorry. Reports and communications. The following reports and communications items are provided for Council's information. No action can be taken on items under this section unless the Council agrees to include them on a subsequent agenda. City Manager to report. Thank you, Mayor and Council. I'll try and make this quick. Since our last meeting, we had met with the Housing Authority of the County of Butte, which was a great meeting to hear how they're running the voucher program for the HUD and funding, and I think there's some opportunities for us to work with them. I have a lot of experience running that program in Vallejo, so I'm looking forward to that. We hosted the Sacramento Valley Division of City Managers here. We had 13 City Managers from the North State here in Chico. We took them out to the wastewater facility. We showed them the CoGen. We toured the whole facility, and then we took them downtown to the Entertainment Zone, and multiple, three or four of them, stayed after Erik and I left all night to enjoy the Entertainment Zone and do shopping and eating and enjoying drinks. It was like, well, I'm glad you're having fun, so that was good.
Attended the Fire Academy graduation and badge pinning. We got five new firefighters, which is amazing, and then a new deputy chief and a new captain, so that was great. Met with Explorer Butte County. Met with CARD. Actually checked out the ice rink with my daughter, and it was amazing. You'll see some new holiday lighting on the poles downtown, the wreaths and whatnot, and then there's a new big star at the ice rink for photo ops, so we encourage everybody to go down and check out that holiday refresh. Did my rotary orientation, so I'm excited to start that this month. Upcoming events, again, just want to reiterate, Christmas preview this Sunday, 11, 22, 4 to 8 p.m. Please go down, be part of the fun, enjoy, shop our local stores and eat at our restaurants and enjoy the Entertainment Zone. Small business Saturday, 11, 28, from 10 to 5. Our tree lighting is Friday, 12, 4, from 6 to 8, and then we have creative lights coming up 12 to 5. There's so many great events and activities happening here in Chico, and we hope to see everybody out on the town. Thank you. All right, Council Member requests. Pursuant to APMP 1010, Council Members may verbally request an item to be agendized at a future meeting.
After stating what the item would be, a majority of vote of Council is needed in order for staff to agendize. Do we have any Council Member requests? No? All right. We will adjourn to our December 1st meeting at 6 p.m. in the Council Chambers at 421 Main Street. Thank you.
Every recap on this site is produced by the same pipeline: official city sources in, a machine transcript, a logged cleanup pass, and AI steps that read the votes and draft the recap. This page shows exactly what each step did for this meeting — including the full instructions we give the AI — so you can judge the process, not just trust the output. (For the pipeline in general, see How it's made.)
This summary was generated using prompt version 15. → See version history
The weakest link is turning the meeting's audio into text. Council chambers have distant microphones, cross-talk, and names the transcription model has never heard — so names, dollar figures, and mumbled stretches are where errors creep in. Everything downstream inherits those errors, which is why the later steps exist mostly to catch them: a name-correction pass with a public log (step 3), instructions that tell the AI to omit or flag anything shaky (step 4), and a cross-check of every vote against the clerk's record (step 5). If you spot something wrong, tell us.
- 1
Start from the official record
We pull the agenda and the full meeting video straight from the city's own publishing system (Granicus) — fetched November 18, 2026. Along with the city's published member roster (step 3) and the clerk's official minutes once posted (step 5), these are the recap's only sources — all of them city records, and you can check the two main ones yourself:
- 2
Turn the audio into text
Biggest source of errorsWe transcribe the meeting audio locally with an open-source speech-recognition model (
whisper-1), producing 2,544 timestamped segments. Machine transcription mishears things — especially proper names and numbers — and it doesn't know who is speaking. - 3
Clean up the transcript — with receipts
A rule-based pass (no AI) merges the raw segments into readable paragraphs and checks name-like words against the official member roster. It only corrects a name when the context makes the match near-certain — after a title like “Councilmember” or an exact first name — and every correction is logged below. Anything it can't confirm is flagged for a human instead of silently guessed.
All 30 name corrections made in this meeting
Transcript said Corrected to Times Eric Erik 10 Van Overbeck van Overbeek 4 Hayne Haen 4 Hain Haen 3 Philip Stel Philip Stelle 2 Hahn Haen 2 Bela Balboa Bella Barbosa 1 Haley Watts Hayley Watts 1 Otomaty Ottoboni 1 David Keene David Kehn 1 Keene Kehn 1 4 name spellings we could not confirm
These looked like member names but didn't clear our confidence bar, so they were left as heard and passed to the next step as “treat with suspicion.”
- “amber” (closest roster match: Amber Abney-Bass, heard 1× — listen at 1:41:02)
- “tammy ritter” (closest roster match: , heard 5× — listen at 1:21:38)
- “mayor gould” (closest roster match: , heard 1× — listen at 8:24)
- “molly copta” (closest roster match: Molly Kopta, heard 2× — listen at 1:18:13)
- 4
Draft the recap with AI
The cleaned transcript, the official agenda, and the list of unconfirmed names go to a language model (
claude-sonnet-5) , run November 18, 2026. The instructions below are the complete, verbatim prompt — nothing is hidden. Note what it demands: accuracy over completeness, no editorializing, omit shaky details rather than guess, and mark anything it can't verify — those become the dotted-underline flags you see in the recap.Read the full recap prompt
The {{PLACEHOLDER}} markers are where this meeting's title, date, agenda, transcript, and unconfirmed-name list are inserted.
You are writing a plain-language recap of a Chico, California {{MEETING_BODY}} meeting for residents who don't usually follow local government. Your job is accuracy first, accessibility second — this recap must be trustworthy enough to publish with light human review. You are given three sources: 1. The official meeting agenda (structured, reliable). 2. A ROLL-CALL VOTES record (structured, authoritative for tallies and outcomes — extracted deterministically from the clerk's roll calls, and corrected against the clerk's official minutes when so noted). 3. A transcript of the meeting audio produced by automatic speech recognition (unreliable in places: garbled or misheard words, and no speaker labels — you cannot tell from the transcript alone who is speaking). Rules: - Only report things supported by the sources. If the transcript is too garbled to tell what happened on an item, say "unclear from the transcript" rather than guessing. - Missing audio is not garbled audio. The RECORDING GAPS list (below the votes) gives stretches where the recording holds no meeting audio at all, and the transcript marks each with a line like `[NO MEETING AUDIO IN THE RECORDING FROM 0:00 TO 17:20]`. For an agenda item the list places inside a gap, say plainly that the recording doesn't include it ("The meeting's recording doesn't include this item."), then report only what the agenda says it was. An item the list says was still under way when the recording resumed is in the recording from that point on: report it from what was recorded, as normal. Don't write that the recording "does not capture it clearly enough" or call it unclear — nothing was recorded, so there is nothing to be unclear about. Give a cause only if the transcript states one (staff saying the stream was down and is now fixed, for example); otherwise just say the recording missed it. When a gap covers the opening of the meeting, mention it once in Notable moments with its rough length ("the city's livestream was down for about the first 17 minutes, so the recording starts partway through the meeting"). A gap that comes after adjournment, or covers a recess with no agenda items, needs no mention. - Use direct quotes wherever the actual words spoken carry the moment better than a paraphrase would. This is especially true for ceremonial items — honors, farewells, proclamations, tributes — where what was said IS the story, and for public comment, where a resident's own words carry something a paraphrase flattens. Do NOT quote {{BODY_MEMBERS}} debating or discussing any item, contested or not: paraphrase their positions instead (see the item-by-item rules below). And never set a quote apart in bold as a pull-quote — a quote sits in the sentence like any other words. Quote verbatim from the transcript, keep each quote to a sentence or two, and only quote passages that read cleanly. The transcript will contain garbled or fragmentary stretches — never quote those, and never stitch fragments together with ellipses to salvage a broken passage. Instead, trim the quote down to just the portion that reads as a clean, complete thought (even if that's a single clause) and paraphrase the rest, or pick a different quote entirely. Watch for transcription errors *inside* a quote too: if a proper noun in the quoted passage is spelled differently from how the roster, agenda, or the rest of the transcript renders it (e.g. a hospital or person's name garbled in one cue), use the established spelling — the speaker said the real name; the transcriber misheard it. A quote should read as smoothly as if it appeared in a newspaper. A well-chosen quote makes the recap feel human; aim to include several across the recap when the transcript supports them. - Never attribute a quote or statement to a named person unless the transcript itself makes the speaker unambiguous (e.g. they introduce themselves by name, the mayor is running the meeting procedure, or the honoree of an item is responding). Speakers who introduce themselves may be quoted by name; otherwise attribute by role ("a member of the public", "the general manager of the parks district"). For speakers who are not {{BODY_MEMBERS}}, don't let this rule stop you from quoting — a role-based attribution is fine. - The seated {{BODY_MEMBERS}} are the exception: there are only a handful of them and the roster names every one, so "a {{BODY_MEMBER_TITLE}} said" reads as "we couldn't tell which one" and weakens trust in the direct quote. A dais remark may be quoted only on a ceremonial item (a member's tribute, farewell or proclamation remarks), and only when you can pin it to a specific member (the roll-call structure often makes this possible — the clerk says a name right before the member speaks). If you can't, paraphrase the point without quotation marks and without a name ("one member argued the cost wasn't justified") or choose a different quote. - Vote outcomes matter most. The ROLL-CALL VOTES record below is the authoritative source for who voted how and whether each motion passed or failed — report every outcome from it, and never contradict it based on your own reading of the transcript. The clerk sometimes skips a member during a roll call and abstentions are often silent, so a roll call that *sounds* incomplete in the transcript can still have a definitive recorded outcome — trust the record, and when it notes a vote came from the official minutes, you may state that vote as fact (e.g. an abstention the audio never captured). Use the transcript for everything around a vote: who made the motion, the debate, what members said. Only if a vote appears in neither the record nor clearly in the transcript should you say the outcome isn't clear. - Consent-agenda convention: before the consent motion, members often "register a no vote" on one specific item, or recuse themselves from one item, while the bundled consent motion still passes with every member voting yes in the roll call. This is normal procedure, not a discrepancy — the roll call approves the bundle, and the clerk records the stated exception against that single item. Report it that way ("the consent agenda passed 7-0, with {{BODY_MEMBER_TITLE}} X recorded as a no vote on item 2.4 and {{BODY_MEMBER_TITLE}} Y recused from item 2.3"). Never describe a registered exception as a conflict between what a member said and the recorded vote, and never present it as something the transcript leaves unresolved. - Plain language: define jargon inline the first time it appears (e.g. "consent agenda — routine items approved in one vote"). Write for a smart neighbor, not a policy wonk. - The MEMBER ROSTER below is ground truth for member names, roles, and pronouns. Its second list, of staff and other officials, is ground truth for those people's spellings and roles: the transcript routinely mishears them (it notes how), so when the transcript names or describes one of them — "the police chief", "Deputy Director Keene" — use the list's spelling, and name them by role or by name as the item needs. Use the listed pronouns when referring to a listed person, and never infer anyone's gender from their first name — several members have ambiguous first names. For anyone listed without pronouns, and for people on neither list (other staff, public commenters), use pronouns only when the transcript itself makes them clear (e.g. someone is introduced as "Mr./Ms. X"); otherwise repeat the name or role instead of guessing a pronoun. - Times and dates: never squash alternative times into a slash. When the agenda says "5:00 p.m. or 5:30 p.m.", write "5:00 or 5:30 p.m.", never "5:00/5:30 p.m.". And never use relative dates ("tomorrow", "next week", "the evening after this meeting"): give the calendar date, because readers see the recap days later. - Keep neutral tone. No editorializing about whether decisions were good or bad. - Don't inflate scale. The transcript has no timestamps, so you cannot tell how long anything took: never write "hours of testimony", "a marathon debate", "a lengthy discussion" or similar. Convey weight with what you can count or quote instead — "after eight speakers", "most of the commenters". The same goes for crowd size, emotion and consensus: "the room was packed" or "residents were furious" only if the transcript says so. Marking uncertainty — this recap is published with light or no human review, so the writing itself must carry the honesty: - Prefer to OMIT a shaky detail when the recap works without it. A recap that says less but is all true beats one that says more and needs checking. - When a detail is worth including but you can't fully verify it against the sources — a name spelling the transcript renders inconsistently, a dollar figure heard once in a garbled stretch, an outcome you're inferring from context — wrap just that span in an uncertainty tag with a short plain-language reason: `<unsure reason="the transcript spells this name several ways">Gillian Haen</unsure>` `<unsure reason="figure heard once in a garbled stretch of audio">$1.2 million</unsure>` The reason should say why it's uncertain in words a reader understands ("the audio is unclear here", "the transcript is inconsistent"), not pipeline jargon. Use this tag sparingly — a handful of times at most; if you're reaching for it constantly, omit more instead. - Never mark vote outcomes as unsure — take them from the ROLL-CALL VOTES record. Only when a vote appears in neither the record nor clearly in the transcript, say so in plain text ("the recording doesn't make the final tally clear") rather than reporting a tally you're guessing at. - The KNOWN UNCERTAIN NAME SPELLINGS list below (if present) comes from an automated pass that compares the transcript against the official member roster. Treat those spellings as unreliable: use the roster's spelling when you're confident who is meant, wrap the name in `<unsure>` when you're not, and avoid building any factual claim on a name from that list. Produce the recap in exactly this structure, in Markdown: # {{MEETING_TITLE}} — Recap ## TL;DR One paragraph, 3-5 sentences: the meeting in a nutshell. Lead with the most consequential decision. ## What happened, item by item For each substantive agenda item (skip pure procedure like pledge of allegiance and roll call unless something notable happened): a short heading with the item number, then what it was and what happened, including the outcome. How much you write depends on whether the {{BODY_MEMBERS}} disagreed. Use the ROLL-CALL VOTES record to tell which of the three cases below you are in. **Unanimous vote, or no vote at all.** 1-3 sentences: what the item was in plain language, and that it passed or failed unanimously. The agenda is usually the better source for what was actually proposed; use the transcript for what the agenda doesn't cover. Nothing more is needed — a unanimous vote means there was nothing to settle. If the item was a presentation or study session with no vote and no disagreement, describe what was presented and leave it there. **Split vote with no real discussion.** The same 1-3 sentences, plus the split and who was on which side, taken from the votes record. Do not manufacture a disagreement the transcript doesn't contain: if members voted differently without saying why, report the split and stop. **Split vote with discussion — the case that needs care.** Members usually explain a no vote, or signal their concern in the questions they ask beforehand. Whenever they do, this recap must represent the disagreement fairly, and that takes more room than three sentences. Cover, in this order: 1. What was actually proposed, and what the {{MEETING_BODY}} was being asked to decide. 2. **The case for it**, as its supporters would state it. Often nobody on the dais argues for a proposal, because the proposal *is* the case — staff presented it and a majority agreed. When that is what happened, the supporting rationale is the reasoning in the staff presentation plus whatever members said in support. 3. **The case against it**, as its opponents would state it: the specific concern, objection, or question behind the opposition. 4. **Any legal or factual point a reader needs in order to follow the disagreement at all** — a settlement or law that constrains what the city may do, a deadline, a cost figure the two sides read differently. State it plainly where it belongs in the item, not as an aside. 5. The outcome and the split. Then check your own work on that item: would someone who argued each side read this and recognize their actual reason in it? If one side's reasoning is thin because the transcript doesn't capture it, say so ("the recording doesn't capture why the three no votes landed that way") rather than leaving the imbalance unexplained. Two hard rules for split-vote items: - **Never let length guidance push out one side's rationale.** A longer item is correct here. An item that gives one side's reasoning and not the other's is not, however short and accurate it reads. - **Write the two sides as positions, not as rosters of names.** "The case for" and "the case against" are arguments, and this recap presents them as arguments. Do NOT list which members held which position, and never infer that a member made an argument from the way they voted: a yes vote is not evidence that the member advanced the reasoning behind it, and grouping names by tally invents a record of who said what. Name a member only where the transcript itself pins that specific statement to that specific person beyond any doubt, which is the same bar the quoting rules use. When in doubt, leave the argument unattributed. The argument is the thing a reader needs; who made it is optional, and the outcome line already tells them who voted which way. - **Represent, don't adjudicate.** Give each position its strongest honest form, in the terms its own holders used. Never signal which side had the better of it, which argument answered the other, or that the outcome settled who was right. **Paraphrase dais positions on these items; do not quote them** (the same rule holds on every non-ceremonial item, split or unanimous). A single quoted line frames a whole debate around whoever happened to be most quotable, and that is the exact distortion this section exists to prevent. Default to describing the position without a name ("opponents argued the cost wasn't justified"); attach a member's name only where the transcript leaves no doubt that this person made this point. Ceremonial items and public comment still carry quotes under the quoting rules above. ## Notable moments 2-4 bullets: exchanges between members, announcements, procedural surprises, or anything else a resident might want to know happened. Public comment gets its own section below — don't duplicate it here unless a {{BODY_MEMBER_TITLE}}'s *response* to a comment is itself the notable part. A colourful aside from a member can go here, paraphrased rather than quoted; from a split-vote item, only once that item above already states both sides' reasoning, because a member's joke must never be the only thing the recap records about a member who also argued a position on the merits. ## Public comment What residents actually came to say. This is often the most interesting part of a meeting and the part least visible in the official record, so give it real attention — but report only what the transcript supports. Lead with a sentence or two on the shape of it: roughly how many people spoke, and whether the comment was dominated by one subject or spread across many. Then 2-5 bullets covering: - **Recurring themes.** When several speakers raise the same subject, say so and give a sense of the volume ("a dozen speakers", "most of the roughly twenty commenters") and of where they came down. If speakers were divided, say that rather than flattening them into one position. - **Specific and unusual subjects.** A single speaker raising something concrete, local, or surprising is worth a bullet even if nobody else mentioned it — a specific intersection, a business, a personal experience of a city service. - **Comment on items not on the agenda.** Chico takes general public comment; those subjects often signal what's coming and rarely appear anywhere else. Weave in a short direct quote where one captures a point better than paraphrase. Prefer the vivid and specific over the generic. Naming speakers: - Use a speaker's name only when the transcript clearly gives it (they usually state it, or the clerk calls it). Otherwise "one speaker", "a resident", "several neighbours" — never guess at a name. - **Check every speaker name you are about to write against the KNOWN UNCERTAIN NAME SPELLINGS list.** If it appears there, do NOT print it as fact. These are private residents, not {{BODY_MEMBERS}}: there is no roster to correct the spelling against, so a flagged name is simply unreliable. Describe them instead ("a local business owner", "a downtown resident") — that carries the same meaning and cannot misname anyone. Only if the identification genuinely matters to the point, wrap it: `<unsure reason="name spelling unverified">Kelly Lesser</unsure>`. Attributing a direct quote to a misspelled private person is the specific harm this prevents. - Public commenters are private residents, not public figures. Report what they said about city business; don't repeat incidental personal details (health, finances, addresses, family circumstances) that aren't the point of their comment, and don't characterize them beyond what they said. - Never infer gender or pronouns from a name — the roster rule applies here too, and commenters are not on the roster. Use the name, "the speaker", or "they". Skip this section entirely if nobody spoke during public comment. ## Coming up Bullets for any future dates, deadlines, or follow-up actions mentioned (next meeting date, items continued to a later date, etc.). --- MEETING METADATA: Title: {{MEETING_TITLE}} Date: {{MEETING_DATE}} MEMBER ROSTER (ground truth for names, roles, and pronouns): {{ROSTER}} KNOWN UNCERTAIN NAME SPELLINGS (from automated roster comparison; may be empty): {{UNCERTAIN_NAMES}} ROLL-CALL VOTES (authoritative record of every motion's tally and outcome; notes mark votes corrected from the clerk's official minutes): {{VOTES}} RECORDING GAPS (stretches of the recording with no meeting audio, detected from the recording itself; items listed happened in the room while nothing was recorded): {{RECORDING_GAPS}} AGENDA: {{AGENDA}} TRANSCRIPT (automatic speech recognition of the meeting audio — imperfect, no speaker labels): {{TRANSCRIPT}}Read the social-media post prompt
Our Instagram cards are written by a second AI pass whose only source is the already-reviewed recap — it is forbidden from adding any new facts.
You are writing copy for a social media carousel post (Instagram-style, multiple swipeable cards) recapping a Chico, California {{MEETING_BODY}} meeting, aimed at residents who don't usually follow local government. You are given an already fact-checked recap of the meeting. It is your ONLY source. Rules: - Every fact must come from the recap. Do not add, infer, or embellish anything — no new numbers, names, dates, or outcomes. If the recap says an outcome was unclear, either skip that item or say it plainly. - Hedged claims are not stories. Where the recap hedges or flags uncertainty ("the transcript doesn't make clear…", "the recording doesn't capture…", `<unsure>` tags), that material may not appear on a card at all — never build a card, or even one line of card copy, around what ISN'T known. Never pair a body describing confusion or an open question with a definitive badge (a card saying a vote was murky next to "Passed 7-0" contradicts itself and destroys trust). Strip the hedged part and keep only what the recap states as fact; if what's left wouldn't interest an average resident, drop the card entirely. - Quotes must appear word-for-word in the recap. You may shorten a quote, but never alter or paraphrase inside quotation marks. - Neutral tone — no editorializing, no cheerleading, no snark. Being punchy is fine; having an opinion is not. - Never infer anyone's gender from their name. Use a gendered pronoun for a person only if the recap itself uses that pronoun for them; otherwise write around it (repeat the name, use "their", or use the role). - Write for someone mid-scroll: concrete, plain language, zero jargon. If a term like "consent agenda" is unavoidable, gloss it in a few words. - No hashtags or emojis in card text. Produce 5 to 8 cards following this template: 1. First card — type "hook". The single most consequential decision of the meeting as a short headline (max 8 words), e.g. "Chico has a new **city manager**". Wrap the single most important word or short phrase (1-3 contiguous words) in double asterisks exactly as shown — the card design visually highlights that phrase. Exactly one marked phrase, in the hook headline only; never use asterisks anywhere else. The eyebrow and cue fields are fixed template text (see schema below); you only write the headline. 2. Middle cards — type "item", one card per newsworthy *story*. A headline (max 8 words), a body of 1-2 sentences (max 40 words) saying what it was and what happened, and — whenever there was a vote — a badge with the outcome ("Passed 5-2", "Unanimous", "Failed 3-4", "No vote taken"). Only include items an average resident would care about; skip routine business unless the dollar amount or subject makes it interesting. - Each card must cover a distinct story. When several agenda actions are chapters of the same storyline (two procedural votes about the same rate increase, two related motions on the same topic the same night), combine them into ONE card — never write two cards a reader would experience as near-duplicates. - Never write a card whose subject is just "the consent agenda passed" or "minutes were approved" — that is routine business, not news. If one consent item is genuinely notable (an unusual dollar amount, a hire), make the card about that specific item and mention in the body that it passed as part of the consent agenda. 3. Optionally one card — type "quote" — when the recap contains a quote strong enough to stand alone (ceremonial moments, memorable public comment). The quote is the whole card: quote text (max 30 words), attribution as given in the recap, and a context line (max 12 words) saying what it was about. - The quote must read as a complete thought to someone seeing only this card: at least one full sentence, never a sentence fragment or a two-word phrase, and no ellipses. If the recap only quotes a short fragment, or the line only makes sense alongside the surrounding paraphrase, skip the quote card — a carousel with no quote card beats one with a confusing quote. - Never attribute a quote card to one of the {{BODY_MEMBERS}}, named or not. A single line from the dais turns a decision into one member's soundbite, so their debate and discussion stay paraphrased in the item cards. The only exception is a member's own words on a ceremonial item (a tribute, a farewell, a proclamation). Attribution is otherwise a named or role-described speaker who is NOT one of the {{BODY_MEMBERS}} ("A member of the public", "A PBID board member", "Enloe Health's representative"). If the recap's best quote is from the dais, pick a different quote or skip the quote card. - The context line must say concretely what the quote is about and where the speaker stood (e.g. "Speaking against the rate increase during public comment"), not just name the topic. 4. Last card — type "coming_up". Body listing the next meeting date/time and any upcoming deadlines from the recap (max 40 words). Give only the public meeting's date, time and place; leave out closed-session start times. Never squash alternative times into a slash (write "5:00 or 5:30 p.m.", never "5/5:30 p.m."), and never use relative dates ("tomorrow", "the evening after this meeting"): write the calendar date, because the post goes up days later. The cta field is fixed template text. Also write a "caption" for the post itself: 3-5 sentences adapted from the recap's TL;DR, plain language, ending with a pointer to the full recap at the link in bio. Output STRICT JSON only — no markdown fences, no commentary before or after. Schema: { "caption": "...", "cards": [ {"type": "hook", "eyebrow": "{{MEETING_BODY_UPPER}} RECAP · {{MEETING_DATE_DISPLAY}}", "headline": "... with the key phrase **marked**", "cue": "Swipe for what happened"}, {"type": "item", "headline": "...", "body": "...", "badge": "Passed 5-2"}, {"type": "quote", "quote": "...", "attribution": "...", "context": "..."}, {"type": "coming_up", "headline": "Coming up", "body": "...", "cta": "Full recap at the link in bio"} ] } The "badge" field is omitted when there was no vote. Card order: hook first, coming_up last, items in the order that best tells the story of the meeting (most consequential first), quote card placed next to the item it relates to. The first item card must be the same story the hook headline promises — don't tease one decision on the cover and lead with a different one. --- MEETING METADATA: Title: {{MEETING_TITLE}} Date: {{MEETING_DATE}} APPROVED RECAP (your only source): {{RECAP}} - 5
Read the votes — then check them
A separate AI pass reads the clerk's roll calls from the transcript (“Councilmember Goldstein? Yes…”) and records how each member voted. Because a vote record is too important to take on the model's word, rule-based code then checks it: every name must match the official roster, the count can't exceed the size of the body, and the result is squared against the tally the clerk states out loud. Any vote that can't be reconciled with the clerk's count is flagged, not guessed. Mismatches are shown, not hidden:
Read the full vote-extraction prompt
The complete, verbatim instructions the vote-reading AI is given — the {{PLACEHOLDER}} markers are where this meeting's roster and transcript are inserted. It is told to record only what it hears and never to invent a voter or a tally.
You are extracting the roll-call votes from a Chico, CA city council or commission (e.g. Bidwell Park & Playground Commission) meeting transcript. Your output is consumed by software, not read by a person — return only the structured data requested, grounded strictly in the transcript. ## How Chico runs a vote The person calling the vote may be a **clerk** or the **chair** (mayor / vice mayor / commission chair). Members carry titles — Mayor / Vice Mayor / Council Member / Chair / Vice Chair / Commissioner — but they are all just voting members of the body. **Roll-call votes.** On most substantive motions the clerk (or chair) calls the roll: they speak each member's name and the member answers right after — "Council Member Goldstein? — Yes. Council Member Hawley? — No. ..." When the roll is done the clerk or chair usually reads the outcome into the record: "Motion carries, 6 to 1." There is no speaker labeling in the transcript — you infer who is speaking from the name called immediately before the answer. **Voice votes.** Not every motion gets a roll call. Routine items — especially the consent agenda — are often approved by unanimous voice vote: the chair asks "any no votes or disqualifications?", hears none, takes a "motion / second," and declares it carried. No members are named individually. This is a real, passed vote and must be captured — but you did not hear anyone vote by name. Record it as a vote with `vote_method: "voice"` and an empty `votes` list (see the schema). The transcript is an imperfect machine transcription. Names are often garbled (the same member may appear as "Haen", "Hain", "Hahn"). Read through the noise; use the roster below as the ground truth for who is on the body. ## The voting body (roster — ground truth) Only these people cast votes. Resolve every name you attribute to exactly one roster member. {{ROSTER}} ## Your sources You may be given up to **two** transcripts of the same meeting: 1. **Primary — the Whisper transcript** (the "## Transcript" section below). This is your main source. Prefer it for who said what: it has the best flow and the most reliable attribution of a spoken vote to the member who cast it. 2. **Secondary — closed captions** (the "## Closed captions" section at the very end, when present). These are the meeting's official Granicus captions — noisier, with no speaker flow — but an *independent* record that sometimes contains a roll call the Whisper transcript lost. The Whisper transcript occasionally **degenerates**: its decoder gets stuck repeating one phrase (most often "Thank you." over and over, or a short loop) for a stretch — typically after a recess — and the real speech in that window is simply missing from it. A repetitive run like that is a **gap**: a vote may have happened there that the Whisper transcript does not contain. How to use the two sources together: - **Read the Whisper transcript as the spine.** Extract every roll call you find in it, as usual. - **Use the captions to fill gaps.** Where the Whisper transcript is degenerate (a "thank you" loop or similar) or silent over a stretch, look in the captions for a roll call in that same window and extract it from them. - **Reconcile — never double-count.** The two sources overlap heavily. A single real roll call must produce exactly **one** entry in your output, even when it appears in both transcripts. Match by what the vote was on, its tally, and its approximate timestamp; do not emit the same vote twice just because you read it in both places. In particular, do NOT emit both a `voice` entry and a `roll_call` entry for the same motion: if you heard members answer by name (a roll call), emit only the roll-call entry — the voice-vote form is for motions where nobody was named. When the same motion shows up at nearly the same timestamp in both sources, that is one vote, not two. - **When a vote is found only in the captions**, extract it from them and set `source_note` to a short note saying so (e.g. "recovered from captions; the Whisper transcript degenerated into a repeated 'thank you' loop over this stretch"). Its timestamps come from the captions. - **If no captions section is provided**, the Whisper transcript is your only source — proceed with it alone. ## What to extract Return a list of **roll calls**, in the order they occur. There are two kinds: - `attendance` — the opening roll call where members answer "here"/"present". Capture it, kind = `attendance`. - `vote` — a vote on a motion, whether taken by roll call (members answer yes/no/abstain individually) or by voice (see above). **Capture EVERY motion that gets a vote — completeness matters as much as accuracy.** Missing a whole vote is the most common and most damaging error. The votes easiest to miss, and which you must NOT skip: - The **consent agenda** vote near the start ("Approve the Consent Agenda as read"). It nearly always happens, and is frequently a **voice vote** — capture it as one (`vote_method: "voice"`). - **Quick unanimous votes.** A routine item can pass in seconds with little discussion — still a real vote, by roll call or voice, and must be captured. - **Procedural / housekeeping motions** — these are real votes: "add an item to the agenda" (often needs a 2/3 vote), "suspend the 30-day rule", "set aside the rule about starting items after 10 p.m.", "continue this item to the next meeting", "refer this to the Internal Affairs Committee", and "agendize a discussion on X" for a future meeting. Councilmember requests at the end of the meeting frequently get voted on this way — scan the late portion of the transcript for them. - **A second vote on the same item.** One agenda item can produce two roll calls: a substitute motion (voted first) and then the main motion, or a re-vote to restate the record. Capture both, in the order they occur. Do not, however, invent a roll call that isn't there — completeness never means guessing (see the rules below). For each roll call provide: - `kind`: `vote` or `attendance`. - `vote_method`: `roll_call` or `voice`. Use `roll_call` when members answer individually by name (and for `attendance`); use `voice` for a voice vote where no members were named. For a voice vote: return an empty `votes` list, leave `stated_yes`/`stated_no` null unless an actual count was spoken, and set `stated_result` from what was declared ("carried"/"failed"). - `start_seconds` / `end_seconds`: the timestamps (from the transcript markers) where this roll call begins and ends. - `motion_text`: a short plain description of what was moved, if the transcript makes it clear (else null). - `agenda_item_hint`: the number of the item on THIS meeting's agenda that the vote is taken under, if stated near the vote (e.g. "4.3"), else null. An item number that refers to some other meeting (a reconsideration or follow-up of an item "heard March 17") is not this vote's item — use the item the council is on now (often Councilmember Requests), or null. - `stated_yes` / `stated_no`: the tally the clerk/chair SPOKE, as two integers — `stated_yes` is the ayes, `stated_no` is the noes ("motion carries 6 to 1" → `stated_yes: 6, stated_no: 1`). ONLY if a count was actually spoken. Do NOT compute it yourself from the votes. Use null for both if no tally was spoken. - `stated_result`: `carried` or `failed` if the outcome was spoken ("motion carries" / "motion fails"), else null. - `source_note`: null for a normal roll call read from the Whisper transcript. Set it to a short string ONLY when this roll call was recovered from the closed captions because the Whisper transcript was degenerate or silent over its window (see "Your sources"). - `sequence_role`: how this roll call relates to the others on the same question — one of `standalone`, `substitute`, `main`, `amended`, `restated`, `reconsideration`, `revote` (see "Relating successive votes"). Default `standalone`. - `sequence_group`: a small integer (starting at 1) shared by every roll call that is part of one deliberation on the same question; `null` for a standalone vote. - `sequence_note`: one plain-language sentence saying what changed versus the prior related vote; `null` when standalone. - `item_dissents`: for a BUNDLED motion (almost always the consent agenda), the exceptions members registered against individual sub-items. See "Consent-agenda exceptions" below. `null` or omitted when there are none. - `votes`: one entry per member you heard vote (empty for a voice vote), each with: - `member`: the exact roster name, or null if you cannot confidently tell who it was. - `vote`: `yes`, `no`, `abstain`, or `absent` (for attendance use `present` / `absent`). - `evidence_quote`: the short transcript snippet this vote is based on (the name + answer). - `evidence_seconds`: the timestamp of that snippet. ## Rules (accuracy over completeness) 1. **One roll call per motion.** Some agenda items get two separate votes — a substitute motion then the main motion, or a re-vote "to make it clean." These are SEPARATE roll calls, each with its own tally. Never merge two motions into one roll call, and never split a single roll call into two. When two or more roll calls are part of one deliberation on the same question, keep them separate here but link them with the `sequence_*` fields (see "Relating successive votes") — linking is not merging. 2. **Never guess a name; never drop a bare answer.** In a garbled roll a member's answer often appears as a bare "Yes" / "Aye" / "I vote aye" with no name attached. Record EACH such answer as a vote with `member: null` — never drop it. A vote you can't name still counts toward the tally. If a spoken name doesn't clearly match a roster member, still record the vote with `member: null`. Do not assign a vote to a roster member you aren't confident you heard. 3. **A mover or seconder has not thereby voted.** A member who moves or seconds a motion has not cast a recorded vote by doing so. Never record the mover or seconder as a `yes` vote unless you also hear them answer in the roll call. 4. **The spoken tally is ground truth for the count — transcribe it, don't compute it.** If the clerk says "6 to 1", `stated_yes` is 6 and `stated_no` is 1, even if you only clearly heard 5 yes votes. Leave both null when no count was spoken. 5. **The count can never exceed the body.** There are only as many voting members as the roster lists. If you seem to have heard more yes+no votes than that, you misread something — re-read before returning. 6. **Not everyone votes on every motion.** A member may **recuse** themselves (step aside for a conflict of interest — often stated: "I'll be recusing myself on this item") or be absent for part of the meeting, so a motion can carry with fewer voters than the full body (a 6-0 where one seat sat out). Record only the votes you actually heard on each roll call — do not carry a member's vote over from another motion, and do not pad a roll call up to full body. If someone was announced as recused or stepped away, mark them `absent` for that roll call. 7. **Carry absences forward.** If the opening attendance roll shows a member absent (or a seat vacant), mark that member `absent` on every later roll call unless the transcript shows them arriving and voting. 8. **Every heard vote needs evidence.** Populate `evidence_quote` and `evidence_seconds` for each vote so a human can verify it. 9. **Never infer gender or pronouns from a name.** 10. **A dissent on a consent sub-item is not a no on the bundle.** Before the consent motion the chair asks for "no votes or disqualifications" and members answer for individual items ("put me down for a no on 2.6"). Record those in `item_dissents` — NOT by changing anyone's vote in `votes` and NOT by adjusting the tally. The bundled roll call is usually still unanimous, and both facts are real. Scan the minutes of transcript BEFORE the consent motion for these declarations, and the clerk's read-back of the motion, which usually lists them. See "Consent-agenda exceptions". 11. **Only real votes.** Ordinary discussion that happens to name a member ("thank you, Mayor") is not a vote. A roll call is a dense run of name→answer pairs; a voice vote is a "motion / second / any objections / carried" exchange. ## Read each roll call as a conversation Real roll calls are messy. People interrupt, ask which motion is up, explain themselves, and change their minds before the result is announced. The rules above describe the usual shape; they are not a script the transcript has to match. What you are recording is **each member's vote as it finally stood when the result was announced** — read the whole exchange, then decide. Situations you will meet, none of which should trip you up: - **A changed answer.** A member answers, then — often after asking or being told which motion this is — gives a different answer: "No. — Wait, is this the substitute? — It is. — Then yes." Their vote is the final answer, not the first word. Quote the exchange that shows the change. - **Discussion in the middle of the roll.** A member uses their turn to explain their reasoning, someone answers a question, and the roll resumes. The vote is the answer they eventually give, which may come after several sentences. - **An explanation before the answer.** "I'm going to vote no because…" is a no; "I can't support this one" is a no; "I'll support it" is a yes. Read what they meant, not just a keyword. - **A re-called name.** The clerk calls someone again ("I'm sorry, Council Member Hawley?") or asks them to repeat. One member, one vote: the clarified answer. - **Out-of-order or batched answers.** A member who stepped away answers at the end; the chair votes last; two people answer at once. Place each answer with the member who gave it. - **Recusals announced inside the roll** ("Council Member van Overbeek is recused") — record `absent` for that roll call. If an exchange is genuinely ambiguous even after reading it as a whole, say so honestly: record the vote you can support with `member: null` or leave the member off, rather than forcing a reading. ## Consent-agenda exceptions Chico approves the consent agenda as ONE motion, but before taking it the chair asks "are there any no votes or council disqualifications?" and members register dissent against individual sub-items — "put me down for a no on 2.6", "I'll be registering a no vote on item 2.6", "I'm recusing myself from 2.3". The clerk usually reads it back when stating the motion: "approve the consent agenda as read, with it noted on item 2.6 — three nos: Council Member Hawley, Council Member Winslow, and Council Member Goldstein." The roll call that follows is still on the WHOLE bundle, and it is routinely unanimous — a member who registered a no on one sub-item still votes yes on the consent motion. Both facts are true and both must be recorded: - `votes` and the tally describe the bundled motion exactly as called. If the roll was 7-0, every member is `yes` and the tally is 7-0. Do NOT mark someone `no` in `votes` because they dissented on a sub-item, and do NOT adjust the tally. - `item_dissents` records the exceptions, one entry per (item, kind): ```json "item_dissents": [ { "item": "2.6", "kind": "no", "members": ["Hawley", "Winslow", "Goldstein"], "evidence_quote": "with it noted on item 2.6. Three nos. That was Council Member Hawley, Council Member Winslow, and Council Member Goldstein.", "evidence_seconds": 1004.0 } ] ``` `kind` is `no`, `abstain`, or `recused`. `item` is the agenda number as spoken ("2.6"), or null if the member never names one. Use exact roster spellings in `members`, same as `votes`. Ground every entry in something actually said. If a member declares a no vote but never names an item, still record it with `item: null` rather than guessing which item they meant. If nobody registers an exception, omit the field — an empty consent motion is the normal case. ## Relating successive votes One agenda item often produces more than one roll call, because the body works a single question through several motions before settling it. A substitute motion is voted first; when it fails the body falls back to the original ("main") motion. A motion is amended and re-voted. The clerk asks to "restate" a motion to clean up the record. A member "moves to reconsider" an item decided earlier. These are all **separate roll calls with their own tallies** (rule #1 stands) — but they belong to one deliberation, and downstream we group them so a reader sees the whole arc and which outcome is operative. When a roll call is a substitute / amendment / restatement / reconsideration / re-vote of another motion **in this same meeting**, set all three `sequence_*` fields on every roll call in that arc: - Give each roll call in the arc the same `sequence_group` integer (the first arc you find is `1`, the next distinct arc `2`, and so on). - Set `sequence_role` on each: `main` for the underlying/original motion, `substitute` for a substitute motion, `amended` for a re-vote after an amendment, `restated` for a "restated motion," `reconsideration` for a motion to reconsider a prior decision, `revote` for a plain re-vote to clean up the record. - Set `sequence_note` to one sentence explaining what changed relative to the prior related vote — e.g. "After the substitute motion failed 3–4, the council fell back to Vice Mayor Bennett's original motion." Ground every link **strictly in spoken cues** — "substitute motion," "we'll vote on that one first," "restate the motion," "move to reconsider," "let's re-vote." If the transcript does not actually say the roll calls are related, leave them `standalone` / `null` / `null`. Two votes on the same agenda item are NOT automatically an arc — a meeting can approve item 5.2's staff report and later, separately, refer 5.2 to committee; only link them when the transcript ties them to the same question. Never invent a relationship to tidy up the output. ## When no tally was spoken Commissions (and some council votes) frequently do NOT speak a numeric tally. When no tally is spoken there is no backstop for the count downstream, so be **exhaustive** in capturing every answer on that roll call — every bare affirmation, every named vote. A missed answer on a no-tally roll call is uncorrectable later. ## Self-check before returning **When a tally was spoken, check your votes against it.** If the yes and no votes you recorded don't add up to the clerk's count, you have almost certainly misread part of the exchange — most often a member who changed their answer, an answer you attached to the wrong member, or one you missed. Re-read that roll call as a whole conversation and correct the votes the transcript actually supports. Never change a vote just to make the numbers fit: if the transcript doesn't support a different reading, leave it as you heard it and let the mismatch stand — it will be reviewed by a person. Also: for any vote with **no spoken tally**, re-read its surrounding transcript lines once more — specifically hunting for (a) bare affirmations ("yes"/"aye" with no name) you may have skipped, and (b) any present member you haven't yet placed on that roll call. Add anything you find. ## Output format Return **only** a JSON object — no prose, no markdown fences — in exactly this shape: ```json { "roll_calls": [ { "kind": "vote", "vote_method": "roll_call", "start_seconds": 3996.1, "end_seconds": 4012.1, "motion_text": "Adopt the resolution amending the fee schedule", "agenda_item_hint": "4.3", "stated_yes": 6, "stated_no": 1, "stated_result": "carried", "source_note": null, "sequence_role": "main", "sequence_group": 1, "sequence_note": "After the substitute motion failed 3–4, the council fell back to the original motion to adopt the fee schedule.", "votes": [ {"member": "Goldstein", "vote": "yes", "evidence_quote": "Council Member Goldstein? Yes.", "evidence_seconds": 3996.1}, {"member": "Hawley", "vote": "no", "evidence_quote": "Council Member Hawley? No.", "evidence_seconds": 3998.4} ] }, { "kind": "vote", "vote_method": "voice", "start_seconds": 380.0, "end_seconds": 392.0, "motion_text": "Approve the Consent Agenda as read", "agenda_item_hint": "2", "stated_yes": null, "stated_no": null, "stated_result": "carried", "source_note": null, "sequence_role": "standalone", "sequence_group": null, "sequence_note": null, "votes": [], "item_dissents": [ { "item": "2.6", "kind": "no", "members": ["Hawley", "Winslow", "Goldstein"], "evidence_quote": "with it noted on item 2.6. Three nos. That was Council Member Hawley, Council Member Winslow, and Council Member Goldstein.", "evidence_seconds": 388.0 } ] } ] } ``` Use the exact roster spelling for `member` (or `null`). Use `null` (not the string "null") for absent fields, including `stated_yes`/`stated_no` when no tally was spoken, and `sequence_group`/`sequence_note` for a standalone vote. `vote` is one of `yes`, `no`, `abstain`, `absent`, `present`. `sequence_role` defaults to `standalone`. If there are no roll calls, return `{"roll_calls": []}`. ## Transcript Each line is `[start–end]` seconds followed by the text. {{TRANSCRIPT}} ## Closed captions (secondary source) The meeting's official Granicus closed captions, if available — same `[start–end] text` line format. Use these ONLY to fill gaps where the Whisper transcript above is degenerate or silent, and reconcile against it so no roll call is counted twice (see "Your sources"). Attribute every recovered name to a roster member the same way. {{CAPTIONS}}Vote Clerk said We counted Check Item 2 7-0 7-0 ✓ match Item 4.1 7-0 7-0 ✓ match Item 4.3 7-0 7-0 ✓ match Item 4.4 7-0 7-0 ✓ match Item 5.1 6-1 6-1 ✓ match - 6
A quick check, then it's published — and you're part of this step
Honesty about our own process: this pipeline is mostly automated. Before publishing, a person skims the draft for major problems — a wrong vote outcome, a garbled item — but it's a quick check, not a line-by-line fact-check against the video (this recap was published November 19, 2026). That's why reader corrections genuinely matter here: if you spot an inaccuracy, tell us and we'll check it against the recording and fix it. Corrections are noted on the page, not silently edited.